Privatizing the commons: New approaches need broader evaluative criteria for sustainability

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Privatization is, since Hardin, often promoted as a solution to many natural resource management challenges, particularly in common-pool resource systems. However, novel forms of privatization are being implemented in unexamined ways. In this article we explore how privatization affects natural resource management from the perspective of multi-dimensional social-ecological systems. We critique the notion that privatization is desirable due to its pure efficiency, and argue that efficiency must be relative to achieving other normative societal goals, in particular, sustainability. While sustainability outcomes often cannot be fully actualized, the processes through which privatization attempts to achieve them are more tangible criteria. First, we draw on (1) distributional and (2) procedural justice as normative societal goals to assess effectiveness of different forms of privatization. Second, we analyze the broader implications of privatization for social-ecological system functioning considering (3) path dependency and (4) spillover effects. We apply these four concepts to examine three different cases of privatization: eco-certification in fisheries, seed patents in agriculture and property rights in rangelands. We argue that the evaluative criteria for the success of privatization are often oversimplified, and highlight how privatization can influence social-ecological systems and the achievement of normative goals in largely unexamined ways.
Original languageEnglish
JournalInternational Journal of the Commons
Volume13
Issue number1
Pages (from-to)747-776
Number of pages30
ISSN1875-0281
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 03.05.2019

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2019, Igitur, Utrecht Publishing and Archiving Services. All rights reserved.

Documents

DOI

Recently viewed

Researchers

  1. Marcus Erben

Publications

  1. New method for assessing the repeatability of the measuring system for roughness measurements
  2. Artificial intelligence
  3. Changing Data Collection Methods Means Different Kind of Data
  4. Mathematical Modeling for Robot 3D Laser Scanning in Complete Darkness Environments to Advance Pipeline Inspection
  5. Control system strategy of a modular omnidirectional AGV
  6. Monitoring of microbially mediated corrosion and scaling processes using redox potential measurements
  7. Modeling of lateness distributions depending on the sequencing method with respect to productivity effects
  8. Parametric finite element model and mechanical characterisation of electrospun materials for biomedical applications
  9. The erosion of relational values resulting from landscape simplification
  10. Applying the Three Horizons approach in local and regional scenarios to support policy coherence in SDG implementation
  11. Competing Vegetation Structure Indices for Estimating Spatial Constrains in Carabid Abundance Patterns in Chinese Grasslands Reveal Complex Scale and Habitat Patterns
  12. Mimicking and anticipating others’ actions is linked to social information processing
  13. Collaborative open science as a way to reproducibility and new insights in primate cognition research
  14. An integrative research framework for enabling transformative adaptation
  15. Robust approximate fixed-time tracking control for uncertain robot manipulators
  16. Performance Saga: Interview 01
  17. Study of fuzzy controllers performance
  18. Other spaces
  19. From "cracking the orthographic code" to "playing with language"
  20. Comparing Empirical Methodologies in Pragmatics
  21. Jackson networks in nonautonomous random environments
  22. The Impact of AGVs and Priority Rules in a Real Production Setup – A Simulation Study
  23. A Control of an Electromagnetic Actuator Using Model Predictive Control
  24. Incorporating ecosystem services into ecosystem-based management to deal with complexity
  25. Incorporating Type Information into Zero-Shot Relation Extraction
  26. Improvements in Flexibility depend on Stretching Duration
  27. Facing complexity through informed simplifications
  28. Machine Learning and Knowledge Discovery in Databases
  29. The model of educational reconstruction: A framework for the design of theory-based content specific interventions
  30. Recontextualizing Anthropomorphic Metaphors in Organization Studies
  31. Switching Dispatching Rules with Gaussian Processes
  32. Pluralism and diversity: Trends in the use and application of ordination methods 1990-2007