Privatizing the commons: New approaches need broader evaluative criteria for sustainability

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Privatization is, since Hardin, often promoted as a solution to many natural resource management challenges, particularly in common-pool resource systems. However, novel forms of privatization are being implemented in unexamined ways. In this article we explore how privatization affects natural resource management from the perspective of multi-dimensional social-ecological systems. We critique the notion that privatization is desirable due to its pure efficiency, and argue that efficiency must be relative to achieving other normative societal goals, in particular, sustainability. While sustainability outcomes often cannot be fully actualized, the processes through which privatization attempts to achieve them are more tangible criteria. First, we draw on (1) distributional and (2) procedural justice as normative societal goals to assess effectiveness of different forms of privatization. Second, we analyze the broader implications of privatization for social-ecological system functioning considering (3) path dependency and (4) spillover effects. We apply these four concepts to examine three different cases of privatization: eco-certification in fisheries, seed patents in agriculture and property rights in rangelands. We argue that the evaluative criteria for the success of privatization are often oversimplified, and highlight how privatization can influence social-ecological systems and the achievement of normative goals in largely unexamined ways.
Original languageEnglish
JournalInternational Journal of the Commons
Volume13
Issue number1
Pages (from-to)747-776
Number of pages30
ISSN1875-0281
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 03.05.2019

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2019, Igitur, Utrecht Publishing and Archiving Services. All rights reserved.

Documents

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Control system strategy of a modular omnidirectional AGV
  2. Applying the Three Horizons approach in local and regional scenarios to support policy coherence in SDG implementation
  3. Learning from Erroneous Examples: When and How do Students Benefit from them?
  4. Experiences of the Self between Limit, Transgression, and the Explosion of the Dialectical System
  5. A longitudinal multilevel CFA-MTMM model for interchangeable and structurally different methods
  6. Key Element No. 2: Applying Diagnostic Forms of Assessment
  7. How can problems be turned into something good? The role of entrepreneurial learning and error mastery orientation
  8. Schooling, local knowledge and working memory
  9. Petri net based EMIS-mappers for flexible manufacturing systems
  10. The role of learning strategies for performance in mathematics courses for engineers
  11. Managing sustainable development with management control systems
  12. From teacher-centered instruction to peer tutoring in the heterogeneous international classroom
  13. Highly Efficient IPT Transmitter Circuit Based on a Novel Enhanced Class B Amplifier for Consumer Applications
  14. The Forgotten Function of Forgetting
  15. Experimental investigation of the fluid-structure interaction during deep drawing of fiber metal laminates in the in-situ hybridization process
  16. How leaders’ diversity beliefs alter the impact of faultlines on team functioning
  17. QALD-10 — The 10th Challenge on Question Answering over Linked Data
  18. Measurement invariance in a grid-based measure of academic self-concept
  19. Logistical Potentials of Load Balancing via the Build-up and Reduction of Stock
  20. Multifractality Versus (Mono-) Fractality as Evidence of Nonlinear Interactions Across Timescales
  21. Points of cooperation: integrating cooperative learning into web-based courses
  22. Fallstudie
  23. Explaining Investment Dynamics: Empirical Evidence from German New Ventures
  24. What drives the spatial distribution and dynamics of local species richness in tropical forest?
  25. Electrical and Mechanical Characterization of Polymer Nanofibers for Sensor Application
  26. Recruitment practices in small and medium size enterprises.
  27. Determining Lot Sizes in Production Areas
  28. Using Multi-Label Classification for Improved Question Answering
  29. Using a Seminorm for Wavelet Denoising of sEMG Signals for Monitoring during Rehabilitation with Embedded Orthosis System
  30. On the role of linguistic features for comprehension and learning from STEM texts. A meta-analysis
  31. Is There a Way Back or Can the Internet Remember its Own History?
  32. Deep drawing of high-strength tailored blanks by using tailored tools
  33. Introduction: A strategy for overcoming the definitional struggle
  34. Sprachen in Liechtenstein
  35. Language Model Transformers as Evaluators for Open-domain Dialogues
  36. Understanding Context Collapse for Social Media Users
  37. Transparency in an Age of Digitalization and Responsibility
  38. Low Resource Question Answering: An Amharic Benchmarking Dataset
  39. Heterogenität
  40. Are the terms “Socio-economic status” and “Class status” a warped form of reasoning for Max Weber?
  41. Microsatellites and allozymes as the genetic memory of habitat fragmentation and defragmentation in populations of the ground beetle Carabus auronitens (Col., Carabidae)
  42. A practical perspective on repatriate knowledge transfer