Performance of process-based models for simulation of grain N in crop rotations across Europe

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Xiaogang Yin
  • Kurt Christian Kersebaum
  • Chris Kollas
  • Kiril Manevski
  • Sanmohan Baby
  • Nicolas Beaudoin
  • Isik Öztürk
  • Thomas Gaiser
  • Lianhai Wu
  • Munir Hoffmann
  • Monia Charfeddine
  • Tobias Conradt
  • Julie Constantin
  • Frank Ewert
  • Iñaki Garcia de Cortazar-Atauri
  • Luisa Giglio
  • Petr Hlavinka
  • Holger Hoffmann
  • Marie Launay
  • Gaëtan Louarn
  • Remy Manderscheid
  • Bruno Mary
  • Wilfried Mirschel
  • Claas Nendel
  • Taru Palosuo
  • Dominique Ripoche-Wachter
  • Reimund P. Rötter
  • Françoise Ruget
  • Behzad Sharif
  • Mirek Trnka
  • Domenico Ventrella
  • Hans Joachim Weigel
  • Jørgen E. Olesen

The accurate estimation of crop grain nitrogen (N; N in grain yield) is crucial for optimizing agricultural N management, especially in crop rotations. In the present study, 12 process-based models were applied to simulate the grain N of i) seven crops in rotations, ii) across various pedo-climatic and agro-management conditions in Europe, iii) under both continuous simulation and single year simulation, and for iv) two calibration levels, namely minimal and detailed calibration. Generally, the results showed that the accuracy of the simulations in predicting grain N increased under detailed calibration. The models performed better in predicting the grain N of winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L.), winter barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) and spring barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) compared to spring oat (Avena sativa L.), winter rye (Secale cereale L.), pea (Pisum sativum L.) and winter oilseed rape (Brassica napus L.). These differences are linked to the intensity of parameterization with better parameterized crops showing lower prediction errors. The model performance was influenced by N fertilization and irrigation treatments, and a majority of the predictions were more accurate under low N and rainfed treatments. Moreover, the multi-model mean provided better predictions of grain N compared to any individual model. In regard to the Individual models, DAISY, FASSET, HERMES, MONICA and STICS are suitable for predicting grain N of the main crops in typical European crop rotations, which all performed well in both continuous simulation and single year simulation. Our results show that both the model initialization and the cover crop effects in crop rotations should be considered in order to achieve good performance of continuous simulation. Furthermore, the choice of either continuous simulation or single year simulation should be guided by the simulation objectives (e.g. grain yield, grain N content or N dynamics), the crop sequence (inclusion of legumes) and treatments (rate and type of N fertilizer) included in crop rotations and the model formalism.

Original languageEnglish
JournalAgricultural Systems
Volume154
Pages (from-to)63-77
Number of pages15
ISSN0308-521X
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.06.2017

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Aspect-oriented software development
  2. Learning shortest paths in word graphs
  3. Distributable Modular Software Framework for Manufacturing Systems
  4. Measuring Learning Styles with Questionnaires Versus Direct Observation of Preferential Choice Behavior in Authentic Learning Situations
  5. Oddih
  6. “Ideation is Fine, but Execution is Key”
  7. Towards a spatial understanding of identity play
  8. Resolving the Complexity-Flexibility Dilemma in Multi-Issue Negotiations: Nested Bracketing as a Strategy to Enhance Negotiation Outcomes
  9. Developing a sustainable platform for entity annotation benchmarks
  10. Machine Learning For Determining Planned Order Lead Times In Job Shop Production: A Systematic Review Of Input Factors And Applied Methods
  11. Foreign bias in institutional portfolio allocation
  12. Gaining deep leverage? Reflecting and shaping real-world lab impacts through leverage points
  13. Preventive Diagnostics for cardiovascular diseases based on probabilistic methods and description logic
  14. Action rate models for predicting actions in soccer
  15. Rethink Textile Production - Developing sustainable concepts for textile industry using production simulation
  16. Pluralism and diversity: Trends in the use and application of ordination methods 1990-2007
  17. Failing and the perception of failure in student-driven transdisciplinary projects
  18. A geometric approach to the decoupling control and to speed up the dynamics of a general rigid body manipulation system
  19. Learning from Erroneous Examples: When and How do Students Benefit from them?
  20. Optimization of waste management systems by integrating material fluxes, agents and regulatory mechanisms
  21. Three-dimensional mapping of residual stresses and crack propagation in refill friction stir spot welded aluminium samples via synchrotron X-ray diffraction and X-ray micro-computed tomography
  22. A Column Generation Approach for Bus Driver Rostering Problems
  23. The Lifecycle of "Facts'': A Survey of Social Bias in Knowledge Graphs
  24. Knowledge-Enhanced Language Models Are Not Bias-Proof
  25. Graph-based Approaches for Analyzing Team Interaction on the Example of Soccer