Peer Evaluation Can Reliably Measure Local Knowledge

Research output: Journal contributionsScientific review articlesResearch

Authors

  • Victoria Reyes-García
  • Isabel Díaz Reviriego
  • Romain Duda
  • Álvaro Fernández-Llamazares
  • Sandrine Gallois
  • Maximilien Guèze
  • Lucentezza Napitupulu
  • Aili Pyhälä

We assess the consistency of measures of individual local ecological knowledge obtained through peer evaluation against three standard measures: identification tasks, structured questionnaires, and self-reported skills questionnaires. We collected ethnographic information among the Baka (Congo), the Punan (Borneo), and the Tsimane’ (Amazon) to design site-specific but comparable tasks to measure medicinal plant and hunting knowledge. Scores derived from peer ratings correlate with scores of identification tasks and self-reported skills questionnaires. The higher the number of people rating a subject, the larger the association. Associations were larger for the full sample than for subsamples with high and low rating scores. Peer evaluation can provide a more affordable method in terms of difficulty, time, and budget to study intracultural variation of knowledge, provided that researchers (1) do not aim to describe local knowledge; (2) select culturally recognized domains of knowledge; and (3) use a large and diverse (age, sex, and kinship) group of evaluators.

Original languageEnglish
JournalField Methods
Volume28
Issue number4
Pages (from-to)345-362
Number of pages18
ISSN1525-822X
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.11.2016
Externally publishedYes

Bibliographical note

The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: The research leading to these results has received funding from the European Research Council under the European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/2007-2013)/ERC grant agreement number FP7-261971-LEK to Reyes-García.

DOI

Recently viewed

Researchers

  1. Tobias Remschel

Publications

  1. Disrupting the rhythm of depression using Mobile Cognitive Therapy for recurrent depression
  2. The Short-Term Cost of Greening the Global Fleet
  3. 'I Cannot Overreach the Senate': Orienting to the Macro-Context of Legislative Debates of the Nigerian Senate
  4. Alcohol intake can reduce gambling behavior
  5. Observer Strategies for Virtual Sensing of Embroidered Metal-Polymer Heater Structure
  6. Local Use of Antibiotics and their Input and Fate in a Small Sewage Treatment Plant
  7. BERT for stock market sentiment analysis
  8. Does sustainable intensification offer a pathway to improved food security for aquatic agricultural system-dependent communities?
  9. Explaining Convergence and Common Trends in the Role of the State in OECD Healthcare Systems
  10. Das Augentierchen
  11. The continued relevance of compromissory clauses as a source of ICJ jurisdiction
  12. A modified epitope identified for generation and monitoring of PSA-specific T cells in patients on early phases of PSA-based immunotherapeutic protocols
  13. Strategizing in NPOs
  14. Diversity and spatio-temporal dynamics of dead wood in a temperate near-natural beech forest (Fagus sylvatica)
  15. Exploring the knowledge landscape of ecosystem services assessments in Mediterranean agroecosystems
  16. Forgetting fire
  17. Patterns of International Organization
  18. Perceptions of Organizational Downsizing
  19. The use of force against terrorists
  20. Welcome home! Introducing SocSES
  21. 'Crawling Jurisdiction'
  22. The importance of interests for understanding retirement
  23. Reprint of: Drivers of within-tree leaf trait variation in a tropical planted forest varying in tree species richness
  24. Towards a Camera-Based Road Damage Assessment and Detection for Autonomous Vehicles
  25. From deforestation to blossom
  26. On the approximation of transport phenomena
  27. Reconsidering adaptation as translation
  28. The politics of expertise and ignorance in the field of migration management
  29. Patterns of organizational (sub)culture and their influence on organizational effectiveness
  30. Chagga women´s connections with nature: fostering relationality through arts-based methods