Meta-analysis as a tool for developing entrepreneurship research and theory

Research output: Contributions to collected editions/worksCritical ReviewsResearch

Authors

We argue that entrepreneurship research should use meta-analysis to integrate the findings of the field. A meta-analytical approach has several advantages as compared with narrative reviews: First, narrative reviews are likely to bias empirical evidence because they are limited by the information-processing capacities of the reviewers (Tett, Jackson, & Rothstein, 1991). This is often a downward bias leading to the conclusion of little positive knowledge in the field. For example, frequency counts of significant results ignore sampling errors of individual studies, reliability problems of instruments, range restrictions of samples, dichotomization of continuous variables, imperfect construct validity, and extraneous factors (Hunter & Schmidt, 2004). These issues usually result in a higher incidence of Type II errors (i.e., rejecting the hypothesis wrongly). Thus, narrative reviews are more likely to lead to the conclusion that there are no relationships between independent and dependent variables in entrepreneurship when in fact they are (Hunter & Schmidt, 1990; Tett et al., 1991). Second, meta-analysis accumulates studies based on a set of explicit decision rules and, therefore, is less biased by subjective perceptions of the reviewer than narrative reviews. Meta-analyses require judgments as well, e.g., when defining the area of the study or coding moderator variables. However, the decisions are public and open to criticism and replication by other scientists (Johnson & Eagly, 2000). Third, meta-analysis is based on many studies and, thus, avoids the influence of single studies. Fourth, meta-analysis controls for sampling error variance and, thus, controls for power deficits of individual studies (Hunter & Schmidt, 2004). For example, the Brockhaus and Nord (1979) study is frequently cited in the entrepreneurship literature for providing evidence that there is no relationship of personality characteristics with entrepreneurship. However, this study is based on a small sample of 31 business owners and therefore, has serious statistical power problems. Noteworthy, the effect sizes of small samples are less precise in estimating a population value than effect sizes of larger samples. Fifth, meta-analyses can correct many errors of individual studies (Hunter & Schmidt, 2004). Since meta-analyses estimate population correlations between given variables, it is important to correct for errors of studies (e.g., unreliability, range restriction, and sampling error) to achieve unbiased estimates. Sixth, meta-analysis allows an assessment of the magnitude of relationships and, thus, provides more precise and often comparable assessments of the validity of concepts. Thus, meta-analyses support the assessment of the practical significance of findings. Seventh, meta-analysis tests for variations in relationships across studies and, therefore, allows an assessment of the generalizeability of effects. If the size of reported relationships varies considerably between different studies, there will be context conditions that account for these variations. These context conditions are moderators that affect the size of relationships. The moderators may include study characteristics, method moderators, and theoretical moderators. Thus, meta-analyses also help to identify areas for new studies. Finally, meta-analysis techniques allow to test more than one independent and/or moderator variable by using methods based on regression analysis (Lipsey & Wilson, 2001). Using such procedures allows to estimate the independent contribution of variables on results, to control for methodological variables, and to test the interactions between moderator variables
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationEntrepreneurship : frameworks and empirical investigations from forthcoming leaders of European research
EditorsJohan Wiklund, Dimo Dimov, Jerome Katz, Dean Shepherd
Number of pages23
Volume9
Place of PublicationAmsterdam
PublisherElsevier Scientific Publishing
Publication date2006
Pages29-51
ISBN (print)0762313293, 978-0-76231-329-7
ISBN (electronic)978-1-84950-428-7
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2006
Externally publishedYes

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Is seashell powder suitable for phosphate recovery from fermentation broth?
  2. From trade-offs to synergies in food security and biodiversity conservation
  3. Entschädigungslose Enteignung russisch kontrollierter Energieinfrastruktur
  4. Emerging Areas in Research on Higher Education for Sustainable Development
  5. Digital health literacy and subjective wellbeing in the context of COVID-19
  6. Die Interaktion von ökologischer Normorientierung und situativen Faktoren
  7. Cradle to Cradle®. From recycling building components to up-cycllng buildings.
  8. Barrier effects in real-world compared to virtual reality macro-environments
  9. AFM imaging and nanoindentation of polymer of intrinsic microporosity PIM-1
  10. Working in East German socialism in 1980 and in capitalism 15 years later
  11. User Authentication via Multifaceted Mouse Movements and Outlier Exposure
  12. The emotional spectrum in traffic situations: Results of two online-studies
  13. Sustainable institutional investors and corporate biodiversity disclosure
  14. Sozialpolitik und soziale Lage in Deutschland, Österreich und der Schweiz
  15. Organisation und Planung des Fahrzeugeinsatzes in einem Chemieunternehmen
  16. Modeling Interactions and Dependencies in Production Planning and Control
  17. Making education for sustainable development happen in elementary schools
  18. IN DER UMWELT ABBAUBARE CHINOLON-ANTIBIOTIKA MIT HEMIAMINAL-STRUKTUREINHEIT
  19. "Global competence" - der neue Fokusbereich in PISA 2018. Ein holpriger Start
  20. Diskursanalysen institutioneller Gespräche - das Beispiel von „Focus Groups“
  21. Development of Early Spatial Perspective-Taking - Toward a Three-Level Model
  22. Anomaly detection in formed sheet metals using convolutional autoencoders
  23. Absolutely continuous random power series in reciprocals of Pisot numbers
  24. A Decoupled MPC for Motion Control in Robotino Using a Geometric Approach
  25. Wirtschaftspsychologie als Studienprogramm in Deutschland und im Ausland
  26. Taking notes as a strategy for solving reality-based tasks in mathematics
  27. Studentische Perspektiven auf die Qualitätsoffensive Lehrerbildung Musik
  28. Konzept zur Neuabgrenzung und Ausweitung des Naturparks Lüneburger Heide
  29. Kompetenzen mathematisch begabter Grundschulkinder erkunden und fördern
  30. Kläranlagen als Quelle für polyfluorierte Verbindungen in der Atmosphäre
  31. Joint production, externalities, and the regulation of production networks
  32. Gut vorbereitet auf den Umgang mit sprachlicher Diversität im Unterricht?
  33. Future-proofing ecosystem restoration through enhancing adaptive capacity
  34. Endogeneity in the relation between poverty, wealth and life satisfaction
  35. Don't trust the machine - KI für das Schreiben von Beschwerdetexten nutzen
  36. Demografisch bedingte Modifikationen der betrieblichen Fachkräfteakquise
  37. Analysis of a phase‐field finite element implementation for precipitation
  38. The Influence of National Culture on Business Students' Career Attitudes
  39. The impact of mindfulness on the wellbeing and performance of educators
  40. Sorgfaltspflichten in der Lieferkette nach den neuen Vorgaben der CSDDD
  41. Parteien in parlamentarischen Demokratien: das Lebenswerk von Peter Mair
  42. Mining User-Generated Financial Content to Predict Stock Price Movements
  43. Les villes artificielles comme espaces de formation de l’ordre politique
  44. Introducing education for sustainable development into Egyptian schools
  45. Herausforderungen der Demokratie: Zukunftsprobleme und ihre Verarbeitung
  46. Gelingende Ethik-Lehre in der Medizin. Erkenntnisse aus der Lehrforschung
  47. First record of Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis on amphibians in Romania
  48. Exports and Profitability: First Evidence for German Manufacturing Firms