Linking modes of research to their scientific and societal outcomes. Evidence from 81 sustainability-oriented research projects

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Standard

Harvard

APA

Vancouver

Bibtex

@article{919ffc40df39486897dba59b3c56e940,
title = "Linking modes of research to their scientific and societal outcomes. Evidence from 81 sustainability-oriented research projects",
abstract = "Sustainability-oriented research has increasingly adopted “new” modes of research promoted under labels such as {\textquoteleft}post-normal science{\textquoteright}, {\textquoteleft}mode 2 knowledge production{\textquoteright} or {\textquoteleft}transdisciplinarity{\textquoteright}, aiming to address societally relevant problems and to produce {\textquoteleft}socially robust{\textquoteright} knowledge by involving relevant scientific disciplines and non-academic actors into the research.We present the results of a comparative quantitative analysis of 81 completed sustainability-oriented research projects, coupled with an in-depth study of six projects, to empirically investigate the assumed connections between research modes and societal and academic project outcomes.Statistical analysis suggests that contributions from practitioners in early phases of research projects positively influence certain societal and practice-relevant outcomes. By contrast, including non-academic actors and practitioner knowledge into research negatively impacts academic outputs and citations, indicating a trade-off between academic and societal impacts. Yet projects which apply structured methods of knowledge integration score generally higher on academic outputs and citations. Moreover, the funding context affects both research mode and research outcomes. Finally, practitioner involvement negatively affects completing of PhD projects.Findings from the in-depth study reinforce a trade-off between the societal and academic impact of interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary sustainability-oriented research. We find that projects which had a double research objective on academic and societal outcomes but which did not specify how to realize both, neglected either the academic or the societal impact during the research process. Moreover, we find that a well-designed combination of disciplinary as well as inter- and transdisciplinary project phases helped projects to meet both demands.",
keywords = "Sustainability Science, transdisciplinarity, research evaluation, sustainability, impact assessment, mixed-methods approach, Sustainability, impact assessment, Transdisciplinary studies, Transdisciplinarity, Mixed-Methods approach, Research evaluation",
author = "Jens Newig and Jahn, {Stephanie Verena} and Lang, {Daniel J.} and Judith Kahle and Matthias Bergmann",
note = "Funding Information: In this study, we combined comparative analysis of 81completed sustainability-oriented research projects (large-N study) with six in-depth case studies (in-depth study) to empirically investigate the assumed connections between research modes and societal and academic project outcomes. The sample comprises projects with a substantial social science share funded by the two major German research funding institutions. These are the German Research Foundation (DFG) and the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF). Studied projects cover a wide spectrum of research modes, ranging from basic research that is barely interdisciplinary to highly inter- and transdisciplinary projects including a variety of extra-academic actors in different project phases. Funding Information: The performed t-test shows with a significance level of p = 0.06 no differences in the mean of Goal_achievement between projects in the mission-oriented funding context (BMBF) and bottom-up funded projects (DFG). Funding Information: We would like to thank the members of our advisory group, Antonietta di Giulio, Rico Defila, Michael Pregernig, Arnim Wiek and Michael Stauffacher, for their constructive and valuable feedback in early stages of this research; the German Research Foundation for providing the funding for the research project “Modes of sustainability-related research in comparison (MONA): Modes of research and their impact on scientific and societal project outcomes” under grant numbers NE1207/4-1 to Jens Newig and LA3024/1-1 to Daniel J. Lang; staff from the German Research Foundation and the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research for their support in preparing the data collection; project heads, researchers and practitioners involved in the investigated sustainability-oriented research projects for providing us with project documents, as well as for participating in a survey and semi-structured interviews; our student assistants Marie Josefine Hintz, Marie Wei{\ss}, Marion Blome, Sophia Sch{\"o}nig, Maria Br{\"u}ck, Silke B{\"o}lts, Alina Langkau, Franziska Steinbr{\"u}gge, Jakob Wondra and Inga Melchior for their long-term and outstanding support with regard to data collection and data editing in preparation for this article. Publisher Copyright: {\textcopyright} 2019 The Authors",
year = "2019",
month = nov,
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.envsci.2019.08.008",
language = "English",
volume = "101",
pages = "147--155",
journal = "Environmental Science & Policy",
issn = "1462-9011",
publisher = "Elsevier Ltd",

}

RIS

TY - JOUR

T1 - Linking modes of research to their scientific and societal outcomes. Evidence from 81 sustainability-oriented research projects

AU - Newig, Jens

AU - Jahn, Stephanie Verena

AU - Lang, Daniel J.

AU - Kahle, Judith

AU - Bergmann, Matthias

N1 - Funding Information: In this study, we combined comparative analysis of 81completed sustainability-oriented research projects (large-N study) with six in-depth case studies (in-depth study) to empirically investigate the assumed connections between research modes and societal and academic project outcomes. The sample comprises projects with a substantial social science share funded by the two major German research funding institutions. These are the German Research Foundation (DFG) and the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF). Studied projects cover a wide spectrum of research modes, ranging from basic research that is barely interdisciplinary to highly inter- and transdisciplinary projects including a variety of extra-academic actors in different project phases. Funding Information: The performed t-test shows with a significance level of p = 0.06 no differences in the mean of Goal_achievement between projects in the mission-oriented funding context (BMBF) and bottom-up funded projects (DFG). Funding Information: We would like to thank the members of our advisory group, Antonietta di Giulio, Rico Defila, Michael Pregernig, Arnim Wiek and Michael Stauffacher, for their constructive and valuable feedback in early stages of this research; the German Research Foundation for providing the funding for the research project “Modes of sustainability-related research in comparison (MONA): Modes of research and their impact on scientific and societal project outcomes” under grant numbers NE1207/4-1 to Jens Newig and LA3024/1-1 to Daniel J. Lang; staff from the German Research Foundation and the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research for their support in preparing the data collection; project heads, researchers and practitioners involved in the investigated sustainability-oriented research projects for providing us with project documents, as well as for participating in a survey and semi-structured interviews; our student assistants Marie Josefine Hintz, Marie Weiß, Marion Blome, Sophia Schönig, Maria Brück, Silke Bölts, Alina Langkau, Franziska Steinbrügge, Jakob Wondra and Inga Melchior for their long-term and outstanding support with regard to data collection and data editing in preparation for this article. Publisher Copyright: © 2019 The Authors

PY - 2019/11/1

Y1 - 2019/11/1

N2 - Sustainability-oriented research has increasingly adopted “new” modes of research promoted under labels such as ‘post-normal science’, ‘mode 2 knowledge production’ or ‘transdisciplinarity’, aiming to address societally relevant problems and to produce ‘socially robust’ knowledge by involving relevant scientific disciplines and non-academic actors into the research.We present the results of a comparative quantitative analysis of 81 completed sustainability-oriented research projects, coupled with an in-depth study of six projects, to empirically investigate the assumed connections between research modes and societal and academic project outcomes.Statistical analysis suggests that contributions from practitioners in early phases of research projects positively influence certain societal and practice-relevant outcomes. By contrast, including non-academic actors and practitioner knowledge into research negatively impacts academic outputs and citations, indicating a trade-off between academic and societal impacts. Yet projects which apply structured methods of knowledge integration score generally higher on academic outputs and citations. Moreover, the funding context affects both research mode and research outcomes. Finally, practitioner involvement negatively affects completing of PhD projects.Findings from the in-depth study reinforce a trade-off between the societal and academic impact of interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary sustainability-oriented research. We find that projects which had a double research objective on academic and societal outcomes but which did not specify how to realize both, neglected either the academic or the societal impact during the research process. Moreover, we find that a well-designed combination of disciplinary as well as inter- and transdisciplinary project phases helped projects to meet both demands.

AB - Sustainability-oriented research has increasingly adopted “new” modes of research promoted under labels such as ‘post-normal science’, ‘mode 2 knowledge production’ or ‘transdisciplinarity’, aiming to address societally relevant problems and to produce ‘socially robust’ knowledge by involving relevant scientific disciplines and non-academic actors into the research.We present the results of a comparative quantitative analysis of 81 completed sustainability-oriented research projects, coupled with an in-depth study of six projects, to empirically investigate the assumed connections between research modes and societal and academic project outcomes.Statistical analysis suggests that contributions from practitioners in early phases of research projects positively influence certain societal and practice-relevant outcomes. By contrast, including non-academic actors and practitioner knowledge into research negatively impacts academic outputs and citations, indicating a trade-off between academic and societal impacts. Yet projects which apply structured methods of knowledge integration score generally higher on academic outputs and citations. Moreover, the funding context affects both research mode and research outcomes. Finally, practitioner involvement negatively affects completing of PhD projects.Findings from the in-depth study reinforce a trade-off between the societal and academic impact of interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary sustainability-oriented research. We find that projects which had a double research objective on academic and societal outcomes but which did not specify how to realize both, neglected either the academic or the societal impact during the research process. Moreover, we find that a well-designed combination of disciplinary as well as inter- and transdisciplinary project phases helped projects to meet both demands.

KW - Sustainability Science

KW - transdisciplinarity

KW - research evaluation

KW - sustainability

KW - impact assessment

KW - mixed-methods approach

KW - Sustainability

KW - impact assessment

KW - Transdisciplinary studies

KW - Transdisciplinarity

KW - Mixed-Methods approach

KW - Research evaluation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85071078716&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - https://www.mendeley.com/catalogue/f761d0eb-a2f7-3704-81c2-31159e0d1965/

U2 - 10.1016/j.envsci.2019.08.008

DO - 10.1016/j.envsci.2019.08.008

M3 - Journal articles

VL - 101

SP - 147

EP - 155

JO - Environmental Science & Policy

JF - Environmental Science & Policy

SN - 1462-9011

ER -

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. The persistent decline in unionization in Western and Eastern Germany, 1980-2004
  2. Introduction of non-native Douglas fir reduces leaf damage on beech saplings and mature trees in European beech forests
  3. Plant functional trait response to environmental drivers across European temperate forest understorey communities
  4. Study of intrinsic and extrinsic size effects on shear bands in metallic glasses
  5. Model predictive control of transistor pulse converter for feeding electromagnetic valve actuator with energy storage
  6. Pathways to energy transition
  7. Drivers of above-ground understorey biomass and nutrient stocks in temperate deciduous forests
  8. The Impact of Power Distance Orientation on Recipients' Reactions to Participatory Versus Programmatic Change Communication
  9. Effect of Temperature and Strain Rate on Formability of Titanium Alloy KS1.2ASN
  10. Addendum to L. Lauwers and L. Van Liedekerke, “Ultraproducts and aggregation"
  11. Humane Orientation as a New Cultural Dimension of the GLOBE Project:
  12. Processability of Mg-Gd Powder via Friction Extrusion
  13. DAS STATISCHE SFB 3-MIKROSIMULATIONSMODELL - KONZEPTION UND REALISIERUNG MIT EINEM RELATIONALEN DATENBANKSYSTEM.
  14. Minimization of answer distortion in personality questionnaires
  15. Drivers of intraspecific trait variation of grass and forb species in German meadows and pastures
  16. A short review on diffusion coefficients in magnesium alloys and related applications
  17. Less is sometimes more
  18. Deformation by design
  19. Linguistically Responsive Teaching in Multilingual Classrooms
  20. Risk preferences under heterogeneous environmental risk
  21. Prospective material flow analysis of the end-of-life decommissioning
  22. Responsible Artificial Intelligence Systems
  23. Soil chemical legacies trigger species-specific and context-dependent root responses in later arriving plants
  24. The Relationship of Environmental and Economic Performance at the Firm Level
  25. AN INVESTIGATION OF LENGTH ESTIMATION SKILLS OF HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS WITH MILD INTELLECTUAL DISABILITY
  26. Investigation on Flexible Coils Geometries for Inductive Power Transmission Systems
  27. Almost-invariant sets and invariant manifolds
  28. Plant diversity effects on aboveground and belowground N pools in temperate grassland ecosystems
  29. Influence of grid-connected solar inverters and mains monitoring systems on the spectral grid impedance
  30. Residual stresses of the as-cast Mg-xCa alloys with hot sprues by neutron diffraction
  31. Microstructural evolution of Mg–14Gd–0.4Zr alloy during compressive creep
  32. The Assessment of Substitution Through Event Studies-An Application to Supply-Side Substitution in Berlin's Rental Market*
  33. Tundra Trait Team
  34. Local perceptions as a guide for the sustainable management of natural resources
  35. The social-cognitive basis of infants’ reference to absent entities
  36. Predicting Therapy Success and Costs for Personalized Treatment Recommendations Using Baseline Characteristics
  37. Not Only the Miserable Receive Help
  38. Cost Minimization in a Firm's Power Station
  39. The perceiver’s social role and a risk’s causal structure as determinants of environmental risk evaluation
  40. Pennycress-corn double-cropping increases ground beetle diversity
  41. Involving Corporate Functions
  42. Selection harvest in temperate deciduous forests: impact on herb layer richness and composition
  43. An IAD framework analysis of minigrid institutions for sustainable rural electrification in East Africa
  44. Opportunities and Drawbacks of Mobile Flood Protection Systems
  45. Spielt es nur eine Rolle "was" gepromptet wird oder auch "wann" gepromptet wird.
  46. Armed to Kill
  47. Working group on dry grasslands in the nordic and baltic region - Outline of the project and first results for the class Festuco-Brometea