Is there an excess of significant findings in published studies of psychotherapy for depression?

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • J. Flint
  • Pim Cuijpers
  • J. Horder
  • Sander L. Koole
  • M. R. Munafò
BACKGROUND: Many studies have examined the efficacy of psychotherapy for major depressive disorder (MDD) but publication bias against null results may exist in this literature. However, to date, the presence of an excess of significant findings in this literature has not been explicitly tested.

METHOD: We used a database of 1344 articles on the psychological treatment of depression, identified through systematic search in PubMed, PsycINFO, EMBASE and the Cochrane database of randomized trials. From these we identified 149 studies eligible for inclusion that provided 212 comparisons. We tested for an excess of significant findings using the method developed by Ioannidis and Trikalinos (2007), and compared the distribution of p values in this literature with the distribution in the antidepressant literature, where publication bias is known to be operating.

RESULTS: The average statistical power to detect the effect size indicated by the meta-analysis was 49%. A total of 123 comparisons (58%) reported a statistically significant difference between treatment and control groups, but on the basis of the average power observed, we would only have expected 104 (i.e. 49%) to do so. There was therefore evidence of an excess of significance in this literature (p = 0.010). Similar results were obtained when these analyses were restricted to studies including a cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) arm. Finally, the distribution of p values for psychotherapy studies resembled that for published antidepressant studies, where publication bias against null results has already been established.

CONCLUSIONS: The small average size of individual psychotherapy studies is only sufficient to detect large effects. Our results indicate an excess of significant findings relative to what would be expected, given the average statistical power of studies of psychotherapy for major depression.
Original languageEnglish
JournalPsychological Medicine
Volume45
Issue number2
Pages (from-to)439-446
Number of pages8
ISSN0033-2917
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 12.01.2015

    Research areas

  • Psychology
  • Health sciences
  • Cognitive behavioural therapy, depression, excess of significance, meta-Analysis, psychotherapy, publication bias

Recently viewed

Activities

  1. Sachverständiger in öffentlicher Anhörung zur Reform des Kapitalanleger-Musterverfahrensgesetzes
  2. Nachhaltigkeit in der phasenübergreifenden Kooperation mittels Etablierung von Kooperationsräumen
  3. Orchestrating temporal macro-structures through temporal work: Insights from the Edinburgh Festival
  4. Bearbeitung von Problemlöseaufgaben unterstützt durch papier- und videobasierter Lösungsbeispiele
  5. Die Asozialität des Privaten. Richard Sennetts Kritik an der Intimisierung der öffentlichen Sphäre.
  6. Sustainable entrepreneurship and the transformation of industries: The case of the apparel industry
  7. Beyond the ius in bello: On the Discursive Preconditions of the Dissociative Mentality of Total War
  8. The role of video-conferencing software in the communicative constitution of power in virtual teams
  9. Schnittstellen zwischen Menschen und Musiken: Paradigmenwechsel im Kontext post-digitaler Musikpraxis
  10. Evaluierung des Deutschen Museums von Meisterwerken der Naturwissenschaft und Technik (DM) in München
  11. Care und Caring als integraler Bestandteil der künstlerischen Praxis in der Frauensiedlung Loheland
  12. Adoption of Preferences for Redistribution by Immigrants or Cultural Persistence. Evidence from GSOP
  13. Hartmut Langes Novelle "Die Bildungsreise". Parodistische Verabschiedung oder Renaissance einer Gattung?
  14. Vortrag: "Paralympischer Spitzensport: Rollstuhlbasketball aus einer differenztheoretischen Perspektive"
  15. Symposium zur Zivil- und strafrechtliche Haftung von Unternehmen für Menschenrechtsverletzungen - 2015

Publications

  1. Relationships between COVID-related health literacy, mental health and workload of school leaders
  2. Community assembly and biomass production in regularly and never weeded experimental grasslands
  3. Influence of Long-Lasting Static Stretching on Maximal Strength, Muscle Thickness and Flexibility
  4. Plant-plant interactions, biodiversity & assembly in grasslands and their relevance to restoration
  5. Switching between reading tasks leads to phase-transitions in reading times in L1 and L2 readers
  6. Sowing different mixtures in dry acidic grassland produced priority effects of varying strength
  7. Mathematische Modellierung eines Raumes zur Nutzung in einem dynamischen Cyber-Physischen System
  8. Managing increasing environmental risks through agrobiodiversity and agrienvironmental policies
  9. Delivering community benefits through REDD plus : Lessons from Joint Forest Management in Zambia
  10. Experimental evidence for stronger cacao yield limitation by pollination than by plant resources
  11. Combined pharmacotherapy and psychotherapy in the treatment of mild to moderate major depression?
  12. Australian Graziers value sparse trees in their pastures: A viewshed analysis of Photo-elicitation
  13. Nachhaltiges Unternehmertum: Unterschätzter Nachhaltigkeitstransformator von Märkten und Regionen
  14. Remote Sensing of Bush Encroachment on Commercial Cattle Farms in Semi-Arid Rangelands in Namibia
  15. The Use of Environmental and Social Standards by German First-Tier Suppliers of the Volkswagen AG
  16. Key competencies in sustainability in higher education - toward an agreed-upon reference framework
  17. Effectiveness of guided and unguided low-intensity internet interventions for adult alcohol misuse
  18. Douglas-fir seedlings exhibit metabolic responses to increased temperature and atmospheric drought
  19. In search of the knowledge triangle for regional sustainable development: the role of universities
  20. Plant traits alone are poor predictors of ecosystem properties and long-term ecosystem functioning
  21. Story-Grammar-Bewusstheit im Zentrum von Literarischem Lernen und Poetischem Schreiben in der Sek. I.
  22. Competition response of European beech Fagus sylvatica L. varies with tree size and abiotic stress
  23. How production-theory can support the analysis of recycling systems in the electronic waste sector
  24. Tree diversity effects on litter decomposition are mediated by litterfall and microbial processes
  25. A framework for disentangling ecological mechanisms underlying the island species–area relationship
  26. Distracted by the unthought - Suppression and reappraisal of mind wandering under stereotype threat
  27. Health literacy and mental health of school principals. Results from a German cross-sectional survey
  28. The feeling thinking talking intervention with teachers advances young children's emotion knowledge