Gauging DNA degradation among common insect trap preservatives

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Laura Sophia Ruppert
  • Gernot Segelbacher
  • Michael Staab
  • Nathalie Winiger

Genetic methods for species identification are becoming increasingly popular and can accelerate insect monitoring. However, obtaining good DNA quality and quantity from insect traps remains a challenge for field studies. Ethylene glycol, propylene glycol, and Renner solution have been previously suggested as suitable preservatives for the collection of genetic material, but a systematic overview of their performance under compromising field conditions is lacking. Here we experimentally test whether and how different preservatives affect DNA quality under different conditions and evaluate how choice of preservative may affect metabarcoding and more demanding downstream applications (e.g., RADseq). For this, we used the house cricket, Acheta domesticus (L.) (Orthoptera: Gryllidae), and tested propylene glycol, ethylene glycol, and Renner solution for their ability to preserve DNA over 27 days in various dilutions and temperatures. DNA quality was measured as DNA fragmentation and success rates in PCR amplifying a COI fragment of 658, 313, or 157 bp. Undiluted propylene glycol and ethylene glycol always retained high molecular weight DNA at room temperature. No high molecular weight DNA was preserved at 37 °C or in any dilution. Nevertheless, the COI sequence could be amplified from samples at every condition. Renner solution did not preserve high molecular weight DNA and fragmentation increased over time at 37 °C until amplification was impossible. The results suggest that propylene glycol and ethylene glycol are suitable preservatives for collecting both genetic and morphological material, but dilution or high temperatures compromise their ability to preserve high molecular weight DNA. For genomic approaches requiring high DNA quality, additional preservatives may need to be tested.

Original languageEnglish
JournalEntomologia Experimentalis et Applicata
Volume171
Issue number3
Pages (from-to)218-226
Number of pages9
ISSN0013-8703
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 03.2023
Externally publishedYes

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2023 The Authors. Entomologia Experimentalis et Applicata published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of Netherlands Entomological Society.

    Research areas

  • Acheta domesticus, barcoding, DNA fragmentation, DNA quality, ethylene glycol, Gryllidae, metabarcoding, monitoring, Orthoptera, propylene glycol, Renner solution, species identification
  • Biology
  • Educational science

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Personal norms of sustainability and farm management behavior
  2. Weihnachts-Song
  3. Parteiensysteme in jungen Demokratien der Dritten Welt
  4. Methode zur dynamischen Anpassung von Reihenfolgeregeln mit bestärkendem Lernen
  5. Principles for the application of life cycle sustainability assessment
  6. Cooperation and Trust in the Context of SMEs
  7. Crown and leaf traits as predictors of subtropical tree sapling growth rates
  8. The Contribution of Education for Sustainable Development in Promoting Sustainable Water Use
  9. The F.D.P.
  10. Der Flaneur in einer "quälenden Doppelwelt"
  11. Semi-stationary shoulder bobbin-tool
  12. Commentary LIAB
  13. Mela Hartwig: Ekstasen. Novellen
  14. Land sparing versus land sharing
  15. Process Development for Wire-based Laser Metal Deposition of 5087 Aluminium alloy by using Fibre Laser
  16. Transdisciplinary Partnerships for Developing Sustainable Food Forests
  17. Between Fostering and Outsourcing Educational Justice: The EU-Turkey Statement and its Impacts on the Education of "Refugee Students" in Turkey
  18. Independence, Accountability and Perceived Quality of Regulators
  19. Situative bewegungssimulation des zweibeinigen, parallelkinematischen schreitroboters centaurob
  20. Bärenstark
  21. Sonnenscheinchen
  22. Towards gender equality in the Ukrainian society
  23. Alkohol Myopie
  24. Ökofeminismus
  25. Optimales Anlagevermögen von Versicherungsunternehmen
  26. Error management or error prevention
  27. PoNa – Shaping Nature: Policy, Politics and Polity. Inter- and transdisciplinary research in the policy areas of rural development and agro-biotechnology
  28. Compressive strength and hot deformation mechanisms in as-cast Mg-4Al-2Ba-2Ca (ABaX422) alloy
  29. Human behavior and sustainability
  30. Kinderliterarisches Übersetzen
  31. Reallabore als Lernräume
  32. Bildung und Emanzipation
  33. De Publieksbijdrage
  34. Enterprise Integration