Evaluating an Analysis-by-Synthesis Model for Jazz Improvisation

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

This paper pursues two goals. First, we present a generative model for (monophonic) jazz improvisation whose main purpose is testing hypotheses on creative processes during jazz improvisation. It uses a hierarchical Markov model based on mid-level units and the Weimar Bebop Alphabet, with statistics taken from the Weimar Jazz Database. A further ingredient is chord-scale theory to select pitches. Second, as there are several issues with Turing-like evaluation processes for generative models of jazz improvisation, we decided to conduct an exploratory online study to gain further insight while testing our algorithm in the context of a variety of human generated solos by eminent masters, jazz students, and non-professionals in various performance renditions. Results show that jazz experts (64.4% accuracy) but not non-experts (41.7% accuracy) are able to distinguish the computer-generated solos amongst a set of real solos, but with a large margin of error. The type of rendition is crucial when assessing artificial jazz solos because expressive and performative aspects (timbre, articulation, micro-timing and band-soloist interaction) seem to be equally if not more important than the syntactical (tone) content. Furthermore, the level of expertise of the solo performer does matter, as solos by non-professional humans were on average rated worse than the algorithmic ones. Accordingly, we found indications that assessments of origin of a solo are partly driven by aesthetic judgments. We propose three possible strategies to install a reliable evaluation process to mitigate some of the inherent problems.
Original languageEnglish
JournalTransactions of the International Society for Music Information Retrieval
Volume5
Issue number1
Pages (from-to)20-34
Number of pages15
ISSN2514-3298
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 03.02.2022

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© Vascular and Endovascular Review 2021.

    Research areas

  • Music education - Generative Models, analysis by synthesis, jazz, improvisation, assessment, performance

Documents

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Activity-based working
  2. Researching Interrelations of formal and informal Learning in early Adolescence form a Critical Race Perspective
  3. Technology-centred learning processes as digital artistic development
  4. Making sense of sustainability transitions locally
  5. Conception and analysis of Cascaded Dual Kalman Filters as virtual sensors for mastication activity of stomatognathic craniomandibular system
  6. Implementation of EU labour law directives by way of national collective agreements
  7. Inclusive conservation and the Post-2020 Global Biodiversity Framework
  8. Balancing the Boundary
  9. Development of tools to prevent food waste
  10. Strategy execution in hospitals
  11. The Diffusion of Values among Democracies and Autocracies
  12. Belowground top-down and aboveground bottom-up effects structure multitrophic community relationships in a biodiverse forest
  13. Differential mortality rates in major and subthreshold depression
  14. You Are Where You Eat: A Theoretical Perspective on Why Identity Matters in Local Food Groups
  15. Cultural change in Asia and beyond
  16. Søren Kierkegaard in deutscher Sprache
  17. On entrepreneurial risk-taking and the macroeconomic effects of financial constraints
  18. Tree phylogenetic diversity promotes host–parasitoid interactions
  19. Big Data - Characterizing an Emerging Research Field using Topic Models
  20. Der Struwwelpeter
  21. When it really counts
  22. Exploring the Capacity of Water Framework Directive Indices to Assess Ecosystem Services in Fluvial and Riparian Systems
  23. Long-term retrospective analysis of the societal metabolism of cobalt in the European Union
  24. Introduction: Modeling the Pacific Ocean
  25. Lernsoftware im Unterricht
  26. Intra-specific leaf trait responses to species richness at two different local scales
  27. An Integrated Case Study of the Concepts and Applications of SAP ERP HCM
  28. Balanced scorecard and controllability at the level of middle managers
  29. From GUI to No-UI