Do Serious Breaches Give Rise to Any Specific Obligations of the Responsible State?

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearch

Authors

The International Law Commission's decision to maintain Articles 40 and 41 is based on the conviction that serious breaches of peremptory norms entail specific legal consequences within the field of state responsibility. Among these consequences, it is possible to distinguish between (i) specific obligations binding on other states, (ii) specific rights of other states and (iii) specific obligations of the responsible state. This article critically assesses whether international law recognizes specific consequences falling within the third of these categories. It discusses six prominent candidates suggested in international practice, literature, and the work of the ILC — such as the obligations to provide assurances of non‐repetition, to pay punitive or exemplary damages or to prosecute individual perpetrators of serious wrongful acts. The article concludes that none of these candidates qualifies as a specific consequence of serious breaches of peremptory norms — partly because the alleged specific obligation has not been recognized in international law, and partly because it equally applies to internationally wrongful acts that do not constitute serious breaches in the sense of Article 40. It follows that international law at present does not impose specific obligations on states responsible for serious breaches of peremptory norms. This in turn raises doubts as to the viability of the distinction between serious breaches and ordinary wrongful acts.
Original languageEnglish
JournalEuropean Journal of International Law
Volume13
Issue number5
Pages (from-to)1161-1180
Number of pages20
ISSN0938-5428
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.12.2002
Externally publishedYes

    Research areas

  • Law

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Hypothesenprüfung, Theorieentwicklung und Erkenntnisfortschritt in der Mathematikdidaktik
  2. Die Vitamine liegen unter der Schale
  3. Paul Paolucci. Marx’s Experiments and Microscopes: Modes of Production, Religion, and the Method of Successive Abstractions
  4. Positive Empathy and Prosocial Behavior
  5. Newspapers and the circulation of academic knowledge
  6. Transnational migration and the emergence of the European border regime
  7. Zukunft Publikum
  8. Correlation of six anthropogenic markers in wastewater, surface water, bank filtrate, and soil aquifer treatment
  9. Erratum zu
  10. The Revolution Will Not Be Liked
  11. APPschaffung der Lehrkraft?
  12. Stakeholder signalling and strategic niche management
  13. Artificial intelligence, systemic risks, and sustainability
  14. Preferences and policy - Consuming art and culture in Baltimore and Hamburg
  15. Léger, Fernand
  16. Arbeitskampf
  17. Software gibt es doch
  18. Ökologieorientiertes Management
  19. Videoüberwachung am Arbeitsplatz — eine Grenzziehung
  20. Overhead Projector
  21. Integrated Reporting zwingt die Unternehmen zu einer konsequenten Reorganisation der Berichtsstrukturen
  22. Guest editorial
  23. International scaling of sustainability continuing professional development for in-service teachers
  24. Clonal expansions of pathogenic CD8+ effector cells in the CNS of myelin mutant mice.
  25. Simulating the fate and release of metazachlor and its transformation products metazachlor oxalic acid and sulfonic acid in a small-scale agricultural catchment
  26. The Collaborative Production of Meaningful Measure(ment)s
  27. Ageing and entrepreneurship