Balancing ecological and social goals in PES design – Single objective strategies are not sufficient

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Felipe Benra
  • L. Nahuelhual
  • María R. Felipe-Lucia
  • A. Jaramillo
  • C. Jullian
  • Aletta Bonn
Payments for Ecosystem Services (PES) are key instruments to foster environmental conservation and, arguably, social development goals. PES are, however, commonly designed based on a single environmental objective (e.g., conservation of native forest areas), and expected to simultaneously fulfil social goals which are rarely evaluated. Thus, to meet social goals, PES design needs to transcend single environmental objectives. Here, we evaluate the performance of three PES strategies composed of different targeting criteria. The strategies were (1) conserving native forest cover, (2) production of a specific ecosystem service (ES) based on a single ecological objective and (3) production of a specific ES based on multiple social and ecological objectives. We illustrate the performance of the three PES strategies for a forest dominated rural area in southern Chile using a Surface Measure Overall Performance (SMOP) analysis. We evaluate the outcomes of the three strategies based on ten ecological and social criteria, namely ecosystem service supply productivity, threats to ES supply, farm property size, social vulnerability, indigenous status of land tenure, landscape connectivity, proportion of native forest cover, number of targeted properties, number of small-sized targeted properties, and proportion of ES supply. Strategies based on a single objective (1 and 2) resulted in higher scores for the criteria landscape connectivity and ES productivity, while failing to improve social goals by targeting mainly large non-indigenous properties. In contrast, the multiple-objective strategy (3) achieved a better balance between ecological and social criteria and targeted mainly small-sized properties belonging to indigenous landowners. Our results show that selecting sound PES objectives is key to achieving a balance between social and ecological goals in forest-dominated rural landscapes threatened by land use change. Relying on commonly employed single objective PES strategies is not sufficient to foster sustainable development.
Original languageEnglish
Article number101385
JournalEcosystem Services
Volume53
Number of pages15
ISSN2212-0416
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.02.2022
Externally publishedYes

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2021 Elsevier B.V.

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Repräsentative Wahlstatistik
  2. IGH
  3. Legal aspects of satellite-based earth observation
  4. Elevational shifts in tree community composition in the Brazilian Atlantic Forest related to climate change
  5. A modeling assessment of the physicochemical properties and environmental fate of emerging and novel per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances
  6. Sprachbildlichkeit
  7. Bodies that matter
  8. Subsidies for learning in renewable energy technologies under market power and emission trading
  9. A synthesis of convergent reflections, tensions and silences in linking gender and global environmental change research
  10. Ökologische Rationalität
  11. Economic Impacts of Climate Change
  12. Birds in eucalypt and pine forests
  13. A theoretical introduction and legal perspective on rule of law transfers
  14. A note on firm age and the margins of imports: first evidence from Germany
  15. Self-regulated learning as a competence
  16. Schumpeter, Joseph Alois
  17. On the Thermoregulation in the human microvascular system
  18. Seeing faces, when faces can't be seen
  19. Management of Biodiversity in Protected Areas with Sustainability Control
  20. Multidisciplinary characterization of the middle Holocene eolian deposits of the Elsa River basin (central Italy)
  21. Bodies without Boundaries
  22. Valuing regulating services (climate regulation) from UK terrestrial ecosystems, Report to the Economics Team of the UK National Ecosystem Assessment
  23. Kooperative Entwicklungsberatung zur Stärkung der Selbststeuerung (= KESS) in der Lehrerbildung
  24. Die Contessa und der Comte
  25. The politics of taxing the rich
  26. In situ air-water and particle-water partitioning of perfluorocarboxylic acids, perfluorosulfonic acids and perfluorooctyl sulfonamide at a wastewater treatment plant
  27. European taxation during the crisis
  28. The Triisopropylsilyl Group in Organic Chemistry
  29. „Beziehungsweise“ werden oder das sozialisatorische Potential von Freundschaften unter Jugendlichen
  30. Kreativität und ihre Bezahlung
  31. Pigous Beitrag zur Nachhaltigkeitsökonomie
  32. Emissions Trading and Corporate Sustainability Management
  33. Mehr Schein als Sein?
  34. Medien-Traum-Protokolle
  35. Empathie und Solidarität mit Um- und Nachwelt