Assessing participatory practices in community-based natural resource management: Experiences in community engagement from southern Africa

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • J. Dyer
  • L. C. Stringer
  • A. J. Dougill
  • J. Leventon
  • M. Nshimbi
  • F. Chama
  • A. Kafwifwi
  • J. I. Muledi
  • J. M K Kaumbu
  • M. Falcao
  • S. Muhorro
  • F. Munyemba
  • G. M. Kalaba
  • S. Syampungani

The emphasis on participatory environmental management within international development has started to overcome critiques of traditional exclusionary environmental policy, aligning with shifts towards decentralisation and community empowerment. However, questions are raised regarding the extent to which participation in project design and implementation is meaningful and really engages communities in the process. Calls have been made for further local-level (project and community-scale) research to identify practices that can increase the likelihood of meaningful community engagement within externally initiated projects. This paper presents data from three community-based natural resource management (CBNRM) project case studies from southern Africa, which promote Joint Forest Management (JFM), tree planting for carbon and conservation agriculture. Data collection was carried out through semi-structured interviews with key stakeholders, community-level meetings, focus groups and interviews. We find that an important first step for a meaningful community engagement process is to define 'community' in an open and participatory manner. Two-way communication at all stages of the community engagement process is shown to be critical, and charismatic leadership based on mutual respect and clarity of roles and responsibilities is vital to improve the likelihood of participants developing understanding of project aims and philosophy. This can lead to successful project outcomes through community ownership of the project goals and empowerment in project implementation. Specific engagement methods are found to be less important than the contextual and environmental factors associated with each project, but consideration should be given to identifying appropriate methods to ensure community representation. Our findings extend current thinking on the evaluation of participation by making explicit links between the community engagement process and project outcomes, and by identifying further criteria that can be considered in process and outcome-based evaluations. We highlight good practices for future CBNRM projects which can be used by project designers and initiators to further the likelihood of successful project outcomes.

Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of Environmental Management
Volume137
Pages (from-to)137-145
Number of pages9
ISSN0301-4797
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.05.2014

    Research areas

  • Sustainability Science - Community participation, Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC), Joint Forest Management, Mozambique, Public participation, Zambia

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. On Knowing Too Much
  2. Leveraging Governance Performance to Enhance Climate Resilience
  3. An IAD framework analysis of minigrid institutions for sustainable rural electrification in East Africa
  4. Differences in isoprenoid-mediated energy dissipation pathways between coastal and interior Douglas-fir seedlings in response to drought
  5. Utilising learning analytics for study success
  6. Zur ‚Privatisierung‘ von gewaltsamem Protest
  7. Mentoring in schulischen Praxisphasen
  8. Discrete-Point Analysis of the Energy Demand of Primary versus Secondary Metal Production
  9. 2 Thessalonians as pseudepigraphic 'reading instruction' for 1 Thessalonians
  10. Effects of segregation of primary alloying elements on the creep response in magnesium alloys
  11. A path-centric account of action-oriented entrepreneurship training
  12. Understanding self-disclosure on social networking sites - a literature review
  13. Surveying the FAIRness of Annotation Tools: Difficult to find, difficult to reuse
  14. Rózsa Farkas
  15. Waving goodbye to conflict of laws? Recent developments in European Union consumer law
  16. Which Relationality? Whose Personhood?
  17. The roughness of neural networks. Jimi hendrix, holly herndon, GPT-3, timbre transfer and the promising failure aesthetics of musical AIs
  18. Comparison through conversation
  19. Deliberation by, with, and for University Students
  20. Die religiöse Konstante
  21. Analyzing pre- and in-service teachers’ feedback practice with microteaching videos
  22. Fragmente zu einer "Generativen Resonanzästhetik".
  23. Microstructure and corrosion behavior of Mg-Sn-Ca alloys after extrusion
  24. Marktdesign für eine effiziente Netzanbindung von Offshore-Windenergie
  25. Cosmopolitanism in the Wake of Forced Migration.
  26. Lineare Optimierung und Operations Research
  27. Influence of Ce addition on microstructure and mechanical properties of high pressure die cast AM50 magnesium alloy