A four-component classification of uncertainties in biological invasions: implications for management

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • G. Latombe
  • S. Canavan
  • Heidi Hirsch
  • C. Hui
  • Sabrina Kumschick
  • M. M. Niskani
  • L. J. Potgieter
  • T. B. Robinson
  • Wolf Christian Saul
  • Sophia Turner
  • John R. U. Wilson
  • Florencia A. Yannelli
  • David M. Richardson
Although uncertainty is an integral part of any science, it raises doubts in public perception about scientific evidence, is exploited by denialists, and therefore potentially hinders the implementation of management actions. As a relatively young field of study, invasion science contains many uncertainties. This may explain why, despite international policies aimed at mitigating biological invasions, the implementation of national- and regional-scale measures to prevent or control alien species has done little to slow the increase in extent of invasions and the magnitude of impacts. Uncertainty is therefore a critical aspect of invasion science that should be addressed to enable the field to progress further. To improve how uncertainties in invasion science are captured and characterized, we propose a framework, which is also applicable to other applied research fields such as climate and conservation science, divided into four components: the need (1) to clearly circumscribe the phenomenon, (2) to measure and provide evidence for the phenomenon (i.e., confirmation), (3) to understand the mechanisms that cause the phenomenon, and (4) to understand the mechanisms through which the phenomenon results in consequences. We link these issues to three major types of uncertainty: linguistic, psychological, and epistemic. The application of this framework shows that the four components tend to be characterized by different types of uncertainty in invasion science. We explain how these uncertainties can be detrimental to the implementation of management measures and propose ways to reduce them. Since biological invasions are increasingly tightly embedded in complex socio-ecological systems, many problems associated with these uncertainties have convoluted solutions. They demand the consensus of many stakeholders to define and frame the dimensions of the phenomenon, and to decide on appropriate actions. While many of the uncertainties cannot be eliminated completely, we believe that using this framework to explicitly identify and communicate them will help to improve collaboration between researchers and managers, increase scientific, political, and public support for invasion research, and provide a stronger foundation for sustainable management strategies.
Original languageEnglish
Article numbere02669
JournalEcosphere
Volume10
Issue number4
Pages (from-to)1-25
Number of pages25
ISSN2150-8925
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.04.2019
Externally publishedYes

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2019 The Authors.

    Research areas

  • Ecosystems Research - impact, invasive alien species, management, non-native species, uncertainty

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Accuracy Improvement by Artificial Neural Networks in Technical Vision System
  2. Learner pragmatics at the discourse level: Staying “on topic” in a telecollaborative eTandem task
  3. Dealing with inclusion–teachers’ assessment of internal and external resources
  4. Long-term population dynamics of Dactylorhiza incarnata (L.) Soo after abandonment and re-introduction of mowing
  5. TANGO: A reliable, open-source, browser-based task to assess individual differences in gaze understanding in 3 to 5-year-old children and adults
  6. Comment on “Stretching intervention can prevent muscle injuries: a systematic review and meta-analysis”
  7. When, Where, and How Nature Matters for Ecosystem Services
  8. Why EU asylum standards exceed the lowest common denominator
  9. Structural Adaptation Triggers in the CAP
  10. An Ecosystem Architecture Meta-Model for Supporting Ultra-Large Scale Digital Transformations
  11. Requests for reasoning in geometrical textbook tasks for primary-level students
  12. Leveraging the macro-level environment to balance work and life
  13. Effect of erbium modification on the microstructure, mechanical and corrosion characteristics of binary Mg-Al alloys
  14. Scattered trees are keystone structures - Implications for conservation
  15. No Concept of form within Sight Can System Theory help us?
  16. Assessing the Bonding Interface Characteristics and Mechanical Properties of Bobbin Tool Friction Stir Welded Dissimilar Aluminum Alloy Joints
  17. The shooter bias: Replicating the classic effect and introducing a novel paradigm
  18. Was fehlt in der EVS?
  19. New and Rapid Fully Automated Method for Determination of Tazobactam and Piperacillin in Fatty Tissue and Serum by Column-Switching Liquid Chromatography
  20. Demarcating transdisciplinary research in sustainability science—Five clusters of research modes based on evidence from 59 research projects
  21. Elastomeric Prepregs for Soft Robotics Applications
  22. A Study on the Impact of Intradomain Finetuning of Deep Language Models for Legal Named Entity Recognition in Portuguese
  23. Managing Multiple Logics: The Role of Performance Measurement Systems in Social Enterprises
  24. Functions of Constitutions
  25. Comparison of Panel Cointegration Tests