DFG-Researchgroup "Cultures of Critique"
Organisational unit: Projectteam
Organisation profile
The cultural sciences research training group “Cultures of Criticism” undertakes a productive revision of the preconditions, roles and validity claims of critique. On the one hand, new technologies and distribution channels have given rise to a welter of unexpected critical and quasi-critical practices. On the other hand, the very theoretical foundations of critique have come under massive pressure – and so, it seems, has the modern project of critique as a whole. What may be regarded as an act of critique and which agents, expectations and criteria take part, is currently subject to basal negotiation.
The research training group conceives critique as a praxis that is always already culturally situated, while its efficacy rides on comprehensive claims to validity and authority. The phenomena under critique are inseparably interwoven with the forms and media used to represent them. Representation thus appears as the focal point in which widely divergent forms of critique and their heterogeneous cultures lend themselves to comparative discussion. Building on studies of diverse concrete critical practices, the Research Training Group seeks to remap the interaction between critique and culture in the history of modernity up to the present and employ the tools of cultural studies to frame a well founded and timely conception of critique.
Spokesperson: Prof. Dr. Beate Söntgen
Deputy spokesperson: Prof. Dr. Erich Hörl
Main research areas
Kunstkritik, Medienkritik, Sozialkritik
- 2025
- In preparation
Logistik des Musealen – Flows, Friktionen und die Auflösung des Subjektes.
Ruhkopf, M., 01.2025, (In preparation) Friktionen | Kuratieren. Für eine politische Wissensgeschichte des Ausstellens. 1. Auflage. . Döring, D. & Vöhringer, M. (eds.). 1. Auflage ed. Bielefeld: transcript Verlag, 23 p. (Edition Museum; vol. 78).Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Chapter
- Accepted/In press
Aspects of Radical Gay Liberation Theory in West Germany's Tuntenstreit, 1973–1975
Branding, H., 2025, (Accepted/In press) In: Gender and History. 13 p., e12829.Research output: Journal contributions › Journal articles › Research › peer-review
- 2024
- Published
Herbert Marcuse and the West German Student Movement
Gerber, M., Kapfinger, E. & Volz, J., 29.10.2024, The Marcusean Mind. Altheman C. Santos, E., Fast, J., Mayberry, N. K. & Simpson, S. (eds.). London: Routledge Taylor & Francis Group, p. 162-175 14 p. (Routledge Philosophical Minds).Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contributions to collected editions/anthologies › Research › peer-review
- Published
Für's Arrangement sorgen
Lochner, O. & Schoen, K., 06.2024, PERMEATIONEN. : Durchdringungen von ästhetischer Theorie und künstlerischer Forschung . Brunner, C., Busch, K. & Ebeling, K. (eds.). Leipzig: Spector BooksResearch output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contributions to collected editions/anthologies › Transfer › peer-review
- Published
Verzetteln
Lochner, O., 06.2024, PERMEATIONEN. anders wissen durch Kunst und Theorie. Brunner, C., Busch, K. & Ebeling, K. (eds.). Spector BooksResearch output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contributions to collected editions/anthologies › Transfer › peer-review
- Published
Verkleben
Lochner, O., 03.2024, PERMEATIONEN. anders wissen durch Kunst und Theorie. Brunner, C., Busch, K. & Ebeling, K. (eds.). Spector BooksResearch output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contributions to collected editions/anthologies › Transfer › peer-review
- Accepted/In press
Feministische Kritik des Strafrechts: Unrechtsanerkennung ohne Strafe? (Schwerpunkt)
Mattutat, L. (Editor), Burghardt, B. (Editor), Steinl, L. (Editor) & Bayer, D. (Editor), 01.2024, (Accepted/In press) Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft mbH & Co. KG. (Kritische Justiz. Vierteljahresschrift für Recht und Politik; vol. 2024/1)Research output: Books and anthologies › Special Journal issue › Transfer
- Published
Strukturell und opferzentriert: Zwei feministische Begriffe von Gerechtigkeit
Mattutat, L., 01.2024, In: Kritische Justiz. 57, 1, p. 71-82 12 p.Research output: Journal contributions › Journal articles › Transfer › peer-review
- Published
A colonial lack of imagination: Climate futures between catastrophism and cruel eco-optimism
Stolz, L., 2024, In: Journal of Political Ecology. 31, 1, p. 759-769 9 p.Research output: Journal contributions › Journal articles › Research › peer-review
- Published
Administering Emancipation: Verwaltung zwischen der »Tyranny of Structurelessness« und der »Tyranny of Tyranny«
Scherrieble, L. & Stolz, L., 2024, Apparate: über Regierungsverfahren und Algorithmisierung. Echterhölter, A., Lorenz, C.-F. & Richter, T. (eds.). Berlin: J.B. Metzler, p. 193-199 7 p. (AdminiStudies. Formen und Medien der Verwaltung ; vol. 3).Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contributions to collected editions/anthologies › Research › peer-review
- Accepted/In press
Science-Fiction, spekulativer Feminismus und strafkritische Fabulation. Strafabolitionismus mit Ursula K. Le Guins "The Dispossessed".
Mattutat, L., 2024, (Accepted/In press) Alternativen zum Strafrecht. Burchardt, C., Schmitt-Leonardy, C., Singelnstein, T. & Zabel, B. (eds.).Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contributions to collected editions/anthologies › Transfer › peer-review
- Published
What could museums learn from the ancestral knowledge of the peoples from the Sierra Nevada de Santa Marta?
Felicitas Sabel, L. & Rawitscher, P., 2024, Transnational Island Museologies: Materials for Discussion. Brown, K., Brown, J. A. & González Rueda, A. S. (eds.). Paris: ICOM of the International Council of Museums, p. 43-47 5 p. (ICOFOM Study Series and Materials for Discussion).Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Article in conference proceedings › Transfer › peer-review
- 2023
- Published
THE RADICAL ROLE OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES IN POLITICAL IMAGINATION AND PRODUCTION OF COMMON FUTURE IN BELARUSIAN PROTESTS
Davydzik, V., 28.12.2023, In: Topos. 2023, 2, p. 153-164 12 p.Research output: Journal contributions › Journal articles › Research › peer-review
- Published
Cross-dressing women in the cinema of the Russian Empire, 1910-1917
Korotkova, S., 25.11.2023, In: Apparatus. Film, Media and Digital Cultures of Central and Eastern Europe. 2023, 16Research output: Journal contributions › Journal articles › Research › peer-review
- Published
Kinder, Küche, Krise der Reproduktion. Ein Mailwechsel über Konstellationen von Sorge-, Lohn- und Schreibarbeit in Romanen von Caroline Muhr bis Anke Stelling
Mattutat, L. & Niehaus, J., 29.10.2023, In: Undercurrents - Forum für linke Literaturwissenschaft. 2023, Literatur und Care, p. 61-80 20 p.Research output: Journal contributions › Journal articles › Transfer › peer-review
- Published
Zukunftswechsel. überlegungen zu den Krisenbegriffen Reinhart Kosellecks und Giovanni Arrighis
Esch, F. L., 15.10.2023, In: Philosophy Kitchen. 2023, 19, p. 89-101 13 p.Research output: Journal contributions › Journal articles › Research › peer-review
- Published
Contessa di Castiglione: Die Femme fatale des Second Empire
Berents-Kemp, C., 06.2023, München: Schirmer/Mosel Verlag. 120 p.Research output: Books and anthologies › Monographs › Research › peer-review
- Published
Editors’ Conversation with German Art Historians Oona Lochner and Isabel Mehl: Writing Like a Feminist—In Dialogue with Carla Lonzi
Lochner, O. & Mehl, I., 15.04.2023, Female Cultural Production in Modern Italy: Literature, Art and Intellectual History. Cham: Springer International Publishing AG, p. 383-395 13 p. (Italian and Italian American Studies).Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Chapter
- Published
The pencil of cheap nature: Towards an environmental history of photography
Levin, B., 01.04.2023, In: Philosophy of Photography. 14, Issue Violence, Part 2, p. 19-47 29 p.Research output: Journal contributions › Journal articles › Research › peer-review
- Published
Strangers to the Aesthetic: Psychoanalysis in the Work of Georges Bataille and Julia Kristeva
Fabian Rauch, M., 01.01.2023, The Bloomsbury Handbook to Literature and Psychoanalysis. Tambling, J. (ed.). Bloomsbury Publishing Plc., p. 309-321 13 p.Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Chapter › peer-review
- Published
A Psychiatric Clinic, a Monastery, a City and a River: On the (Artistic) Legibility of Disappearance in Topography
Eduardo Dávila, S. & Jordan, U., 2023, On Withdrawal: Scenes of Refusal, Disappearance, and Resilience in Art and Cultural Practices. Eduardo Dávila, S., John, R. H., Jordan, U., Wulff, N., Sieber, J. & Schneider, T. (eds.). Berlin/Zürich: Diaphanes Verlag, p. 209-236 28 p.Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contributions to collected editions/anthologies › Research › peer-review
- Published
Die Contessa und der Comte: Virginia Oldoini und Olympe Aguado: Frühe Autorenfotografie und ihr Umgang mit Studio und Hintergrund
Berents-Kemp, C. & Kemp, W., 2023, In: Fotogeschichte: Beiträge zur Geschichte und Ästhetik der Fotografie. 43, 170, p. 5-12 8 p.Research output: Journal contributions › Journal articles › Research › peer-review
- Published
In the Aftermath of Violence. On Being Present and Calling Into Presence
Taylor, D., Eduardo Dávila, S. & Jordan, U., 2023, On Withdrawal: Scenes of Refusal, Disappearance, and Resilience in Art and Cultural Practices. Eduardo Dávila, S., John, R. H., Jordan, U., Schneider, T., Sieber, J. & Wulff, N. (eds.). Zürich: Diaphanes Verlag, p. 159-176 18 p. ( Critical stances).Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contributions to collected editions/anthologies › Research › peer-review
- Published
Is Code Law? Kritik in Zeiten algorithmischer Gouvernementalität
Mattutat, L., Stubenrauch, H. & Warnsholdt, C. L., 2023, Kritik postdigital. Hille, L. & Wentz, D. (eds.). Lüneburg: meson press, p. 21-42 22 p. (Digital Cultures Series).Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contributions to collected editions/anthologies › Research
- Published
Ohne Lehrsatz und Methode: Kritische Theorie als geistige Praxis
Mattutat, L., 2023, In: Zeitschrift für kritische Theorie. 29, 56/57, p. 99-113 15 p.Research output: Journal contributions › Journal articles › Transfer › peer-review
- Published
On Withdrawal: Scenes of Refusal, Disappearance, and Resilience in Art and Cultural Practices
Eduardo Dávila, S. (Editor), John, R. H. (Editor), Jordan, U. (Editor), Wulff, N. (Editor), Sieber, J. (Editor) & Schneider, T. (Editor), 2023, Berlin/Zürich: Diaphanes Verlag. 384 p.Research output: Books and anthologies › Collected editions and anthologies › Research
- 2022
- Published
Hommage an die unbekannten Betrachter*innen
Schneider, T., 12.2022, Christoph John - Parallaxis. John, C. & Schneider, T. (eds.). Hannover: Palm Press Publishing, p. 30-31 2 p.Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contribution of Exihibition catalogues › Transfer
- Published
Hommage to the unknown viewers
Schneider, T., 12.2022, Christoph John - Parallaxis. John, C. & Schneider, T. (eds.). Hannover: Palm Press Publishing, p. 44-45 2 p.Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contribution of Exihibition catalogues › Transfer
- Published
Mach mal: Oder Produktion ist anderswo
Hafner, H.-J. & Schneider, T., 28.07.2022, Involvierte Autonomie. : Künstlerische Praxis zwischen Engagement und Eigenlogik. Eusterschulte, B. & Krüger, C. (eds.). Bielefeld: transcript Verlag, p. 127-150 24 p.Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contributions to collected editions/anthologies › Transfer › peer-review
- Published
Cutting Across Lines: Lil Picard and the Reorienting Effects of Collage
Lochner, O., 06.2022, Compressed Utterances : Collage in a Germanic Context after 1912. Collins, C. (ed.). Oxford, Bern, Berlin ua.: Peter Lang Verlag, p. 221-252 (German Visual Culture; vol. 12).Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contributions to collected editions/anthologies › Transfer › peer-review
- Published
Visiting the Colección Poyón, or Indigeneity and the Nation-State in Guatemala: Performing the Nation for Two Hundred Years
Eduardo, S., 27.05.2022, Museums, Transculturality, and the Nation-State : Case Studies from a Global Context. Leeb, S. & Samuel, N. (eds.). Bielefeld: transcript Verlag, p. 213-240 28 p. (Edition Museum; vol. 52).Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contributions to collected editions/anthologies › Research › peer-review
- Published
Queering
John, R. H., 01.04.2022, Why Art Criticism? : A Reader. Söntgen, B. & Voss, J. (eds.). Berlin: Hatje Cantz Verlag, p. 415-427 13 p. (Zeitgenössische Kunst).Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contributions to collected editions/anthologies › Transfer › peer-review
- Published
Undisciplined: Peter Gorsen
Schneider, T., 01.04.2022, Why Art Criticism? : A Reader. Söntgen, B. & Voss, J. (eds.). Berlin: Hatje Cantz Verlag, p. 165-166 2 p.Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contributions to collected editions/anthologies › Transfer › peer-review
- Published
Gathering Voices, Feeling Relations: Arlene Raven
Lochner, O., 04.2022, Why Art Criticism? : A Reader. Söntgen, B. & Voss, J. (eds.). Berlin: Hatje Cantz Verlag, p. 249-250 2 p.Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contributions to collected editions/anthologies › Transfer › peer-review
- Published
Beneath the Second Skin. Mayan Textiles and Bodies in the Art of Manuel Tzoc Bucup and Sandra Monterroso
Eduardo, S., 29.03.2022, In: Miradas. Zeitschrift für Kunst und Kulturgeschichte der Amerikas und der iberischen Halbinsel. 6, 2, p. 104-125 22 p.Research output: Journal contributions › Journal articles › Research › peer-review
- Published
Juan E. De Castro. Bread and Beauty - The Cultural Politics of José Carlos Mariátegui
Hahn, T., 14.03.2022, Canterbury : Marx and Philosophy Society.Research output: other publications › Articles in scientific forums or blogs › Transfer
- Published
Wege der Anti-Dialektik
Nigro, R., 01.01.2022, Zweite Natur: Stuttgarter Hegel-Kongress 2017. Honneth, A. & Julia, C. (eds.). Frankfurt am Main: Vittorio Klostermann, p. 273-284 12 p. (GEIST UND GESCHICHTE; vol. 6)(Veröffentlichungen der Internationalen Hegel-Vereinigung ; vol. 30).Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contributions to collected editions/anthologies › Research › peer-review
- Published
City, not sorry: 10 Jahre Kultur der Metropole
Kriszio, J. (Editor), Niemann, K. (Editor) & Ruhkopf, M. (Editor), 01.2022, Hamburg: HafenCity Universität Hamburg. 111 p.Research output: Books and anthologies › Collected editions and anthologies › Research
- Published
Die Stadt studieren
Ruhkopf, M., 01.2022, City, not sorry: 10 Jahre Kultur der Metropole. Kriszio, J., Niemann, K. & Ruhkopf , M. (eds.). Hamburg: HafenCity Universität Hamburg, p. 14-15 2 p.Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contributions to collected editions/anthologies › Research › peer-review
- Published
Ein vielfältiges Bild von Stadt vermitteln
Kriszio, J. & Ruhkopf, M., 01.2022, City, not sorry: 10 Jahre Kultur der Metropole. Kriszio, J., Niemann, K. & Ruhkopf, M. (eds.). Hamburg: HafenCity Universität Hamburg, p. 38-39 2 p.Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contributions to collected editions/anthologies › Research › peer-review
- Published
Dada postkolonial: Die Wi(e)der-Aufführung als kuratorische Praxis
Felicitas Sabel, L., 2022, The Return of DADA / Die Wiederkehr von DADA / Le Retour de DADA: DADA Exhibitions / DADA-Ausstellungen / Expositions DADA. Mareuge, A. & Sandro, Z. (eds.). Dijon: Les Presses du Réel, Vol. 2. p. 63-78 16 p.Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Article in conference proceedings › Research › peer-review
- Published
Der Mucha - Ein Anfangsverdacht: Kunstsammlung NRW, K20 + K21 03.09.2022 – 22.01.2023
Schneider, T., 2022, In: Kunstforum international. 2022, 285, p. 253-254 2 p.Research output: Journal contributions › Journal articles › Transfer › peer-review
- Published
Emanzipation und Gewalt: Feministische Rechtskritik mit Karl Marx, Jacques Derrida und Gilles Deleuze
Mattutat, L., 2022, Berlin: J.B. Metzler. 222 p. (Philosophie & Kritik. Neue Beiträge zur politischen Philosophie und Kritischen Theorie)Research output: Books and anthologies › Book
- Published
Femizide. Versuch einer hegemonietheoretischen Deutung der Rechtsprechung
Mattutat, L., 2022, In: Kritische Justiz. 55, 4, p. 453-466 14 p.Research output: Journal contributions › Journal articles › Transfer › peer-review
- Published
Freie Rede
Schneider, T., 2022, In: 21: Inquiries into Art, History, and the Visual. Beiträge zur Kunstgeschichte und visuellen Kultur. 3, 2, p. 511-527 17 p.Research output: Journal contributions › Journal articles › Transfer › peer-review
- Published
Im Zeichen des Zweifel(n)s. Madame Realism: oder: Die Funktion der Fiktion in der Kunstkritik
Mehl, I., 2022, München: edition metzel. 360 p.Research output: Books and anthologies › Monographs › Research
- Published
Liquidity - Networks - Deterritorialisation: Allan Sekula's Critique of Flow
Kuhn, H., 2022, Fluidity : Materials in Motion. Finke, M. & Nakas, K. (eds.). Berlin: Dietrich Reimer Verlag, p. 39-58 20 p.Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contributions to collected editions/anthologies › Research › peer-review
- Published
Schuldiger Realismus
Volz, J., 2022, Art Germania Miami Beach: Jody Korbach, Nicolai Saur, Nicholas Warburg. Hannover: feinkunst e.V., p. 14-21 8 p.Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contribution of Exihibition catalogues › Transfer
- Published
Theoretical Practices: Review of Natalia Romé, For Theory: Althusser and the Politics of Time
Hahn, T., 2022, In: Radical Philosophy. Spring 2022, RP 2.12, p. 90-93 4 p.Research output: Journal contributions › Critical reviews › Transfer
- 2021
- Published
Die Wait Watchers
Schneider, T., 10.12.2021, Aus alter Wurzel neue Kraft. Berresheims, T. (ed.). Aachen: Studios New Amerika, p. 27-42 16 p.Research output: Contributions to collected editions/works › Contribution of Exihibition catalogues › Transfer