Who are "the people" in the German Constitution? A critique of, and contribution to, the debate about the right of foreigners to vote in multi-level democracies

Publikation: Beiträge in ZeitschriftenZeitschriftenaufsätzeTransfer

Authors

Democracy means power to the people, but it is not always clear who belongs to ‘the people’. The question has become pertinent in the age of migration where large groups of foreigners permanently reside outside their countries of nationality. The economic, cultural, and political integration of these foreigners is one of the pressing problems faced by democratic States in both the developed and developing worlds. One question is : whether resident non-citizens should be granted the right to vote. The answer to this question depends on who belongs to ‘the people’. In federal and quasi-federal States with multiple levels of government the further question arises : whether ‘the people’ is a homogenous concept that applies uniformly across all levels of government. This article contributes to the debate about the right of foreigners to vote in democratic States with multiple levels of government, such as, South Africa and Kenya. It does so by discussing the German response to the problems mentioned above. The dominant view of the German Federal Constitutional Court since the 1990s has been that ‘the people’ only includes ‘German citizens’ , and that attempts by lower levels of government to extend the right to vote to foreigners from Africa and elsewhere are unconstitutional. In this article I explore and critique this conventional view. I then present a positive case for the extension of voting rights to resident non-citizens under the German Constitution. Many of the arguments would apply with equal force to the debate about the right to vote of foreigners in African multi-level democracies, such as, South Africa and Kenya.
OriginalspracheEnglisch
ZeitschriftLaw, Democracy and Development
Jahrgang24
Seiten (von - bis)1-26
Anzahl der Seiten26
ISSN1028-1053
DOIs
PublikationsstatusErschienen - 2020

Zuletzt angesehen

Publikationen

  1. Low-intensity agricultural landscapes in Transylvania support high butterfly diversity
  2. Formen für Kunst in der Realität
  3. Evaluating complex mental health care in outpatient care in rural Lower Saxony: an ecologic study
  4. Artikel 28 AEUV [Zollunion]
  5. Radical beauty
  6. Der räumlich-zeitliche Zusammenhang des § 249 StGB
  7. Risk preferences under heterogeneous environmental risk
  8. Internetbasierte Nachhaltigkeitskommunikation
  9. Key aspects of a sustainable health insurance system in Germany
  10. Nachhaltige Entwicklung in der Hochschullehre
  11. Kollaborative Wissensnetzwerke in "Lernenden Verwaltungen"
  12. Wiesing, Lambert: Das Mich der Wahrnehmung. Eine Autopsie, Suhrkamp Verlag 2009
  13. Grundwissen Christentum Bd. 2
  14. Viertklässler diskutieren: Was können wir tun, damit jeder Arbeit hat?
  15. § 32 Solare Strahlungsenergie
  16. Gendersensible Didaktik
  17. Regulierung der nachhaltigen Corporate Governance?
  18. Die forschungsbasierte Ausgestaltung der Studieneingangsphase in den Ingenieurwissenschaften
  19. Existenzgründung als geplantes Verhalten
  20. Wo lernen Kinder mit sonderpädagogischem Förderbedarf besser?
  21. Ungewolltes Lernen als Risiko im Hause des Lernens
  22. Lokale Agenda 21 als Gestaltungsebene für Nachhaltigkeit
  23. Reflektieren/Transzendieren
  24. Die vier Verschiebungen des Blicks
  25. Strukturen pädagogischer Wahrnehmung
  26. Universals
  27. Neuere Arbeiten zur deutschsprachigen Emigration nach 1933
  28. Irreversibility, ignorance, and the intergenerational equity-efficieny trade-off
  29. Complementarity, impatience, and the resilience of natural-resource-dependent economies