What enables metals ‘being’ ‘responsible’? An exploratory study on the enabling of organizational identity claims through a new sustainability standard

Publikation: Beiträge in ZeitschriftenZeitschriftenaufsätzeForschungbegutachtet

Authors

Claims about resource sustainability abound in business communications. Yet, little do we know about how such claims are enabled amidst ongoing controversy of industrial and organizational benefits. Here, we propose to approach these claims through the concept of organizational sustainability identities (OSIs), which are claims serving as sustainable identifiers, and whose meanings are co-constructed by stakeholders. We assess how a new voluntary sustainability standard (VSS) of the metals industry is driven by a mission to enable an OSI for the product of its members, such as that their metal ‘is’ ‘responsible’, and how the members attain this through the structural conditions set by the new scheme. We present an exploratory case study that is based on data from a content analysis of standards texts and thematic analysis of stakeholder interviews. We find that VSS enable OSIs through a) an advanced performance rationale, b) the creation of a community of practice, c) members' perceptions of altered power relations among value chain stakeholders, and d) the facilitation of a platform to keep defining the ‘responsible metal’. We contribute to the discussions of VSS emergence and their effectiveness, for which we highlight the prolificness of the OSI concept and introduce a novel comparative method of provision type analysis to capture the developments of performance rationales.
OriginalspracheEnglisch
Aufsatznummer103619
ZeitschriftResources Policy
Jahrgang83
Seiten (von - bis)1-10
Anzahl der Seiten10
ISSN0301-4207
DOIs
PublikationsstatusErschienen - 01.06.2023

Bibliographische Notiz

Funding Information:
In further accordance with our findings from the first part of this study (cf. Fig. 3), we were also able to identify among the stakeholder accounts a gap about whether MSS fulfils all relevant levels of performance. Given the focus on how the industry performs, there is a gap towards providing detailed and tangible objectives of performance that allow for sustainability claims about product itself, meaning that despite an augmented performance rationale, this rationale does not support OSI directly. One stakeholder emphasizes this insight:The response to reputational issues of the industry by establishing a community of practice supports the possibility of using common identifiers, such as the OSI referring to one's product as a ‘responsible metal’ (see also Levy et al., 2016). Our findings also go here beyond previous insights on VSS, specifically about how these are platforms for deliberation and negotiation between stakeholders (Scherer and Palazzo, 2007; Schouten et al., 2012). We find in the assessed case of a newly emerging VSS, that the ability to deliberate on meanings of OSI in relation to business practices is an essential purpose of the initiative. Interview data suggests that multi-stakeholder deliberation about the meaning of the ‘responsible metal’ for the industry was a founding impetus for the initiative, and continues to be part of ongoing standard development. This ongoing development includes certified businesses contesting the value of MSS by proposing that, for some organizations in the value chain, applied practices go beyond what MSS can cover in its provisions resulting from stakeholder deliberation. Our insight, therefore, that MSS serves the industry as a discursive platform about the meanings of an OSI and related practices, is an essential feature of the value which the initiative adds to the standard field. We also consider the finding about perceived changing power relations among stakeholders in this light, as the discursive platform seems to assist reducing and balancing power of particular actors over the value chain, as well as their influence over the industry's reputation. This finding thus also adds to the sustainable supply chain literature, which usually considers buyer firms at the downstream end as leaders that bring sustainability to the further upstream partners of the value chain (e.g. Hoejmose et al., 2013; Imbrogiano and Steiner, 2022; Seuring and Müller, 2008; Villena and Gioia, 2018). MSS appears in our study also as a means to balance unidirectional power exertion, sustainability claims and pressures on parts of the value chain.We are thankful for Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH having financially supported the first part of the research.

Funding Information:
We are thankful for Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH having financially supported the first part of the research.

Publisher Copyright:
© 2023 The Authors

DOI

Zuletzt angesehen

Aktivitäten

  1. Digitale Unterstützung des Schreibens im sprachlich heterogenen Deutschunterricht - Eine DBR-Studie an berufsbildenden Schulen in Hamburg & Niedersachsen
  2. Effects of an Internet-based guided self-help intervention for college women with eating disorders: Long-term results from a large randomized controlled trial.
  3. Personal norms of sustainability and their consequences in ecological-economic systems under uncertainty – The case of rangeland management in semi-arid regions
  4. Implementing an Internet-based platform for eating disorder screening, prevention, and treatment on college campuses: Preliminary results from a state-wide initiative.
  5. Prima Conferencia Internacional “Alternativas de desarrollo sostenible: cómo cambiar el paradigma social con énfasis en la centralidad del ser humano y la naturaleza” 2012
  6. Institutionenübergreifende Kooperationen in der Lehrkräftebildung: Konzeptionelle Ansätze, Zugänge zur Begleitforschung sowie Befunde zu Potenzialen und Herausforderungen
  7. 5th International Conference of the Sustainable Consumption Research and Action Initiative (SCORAI), 21st European Roundtable on Sustainable Consumption and Production (ERSCP)
  8. (Beruflichen) Herausforderungen der Nachhaltigkeitstransformation mit Methoden der Gamification begegnen – Mobile Escape Rooms als Resonanzräume spielerisch-transformativen Lernens
  9. Forschendes Lernen zum Whole School Approach als doppelter Lernanlass von Studierenden und schulischem Berufsbildungspersonal – Konzeption und Umsetzung eines universitären Seminars
  10. Hochschulöffentlicher Vortrag: Citizenship Education and Student Protests - Einblicke in ein binationales Forschungsprojekt zum Thema Citizenship Education in South Africa and Germany"
  11. Hochschulöffentlicher Vortrag: "Citizenship Education and Student Protests - Einblicke in ein binationales Forschungsprojekt zum Thema Citizenship Education in South Africa and Germany"
  12. Mehr Nachhaltigkeit im Wirtschaftsunterricht: Eine qualitative Exploration von Nachhaltigkeitsberichten als Grundlage von arbeits- und geschäftsprozessorientierten Lehr-Lern-Arrangements
  13. „Whole School Approach" als Anspruch einer ganzheitlichen Berufsbildung für nachhaltige Entwicklung im Lernort berufsbildende Schule – Theoretische Konzeptionen und empirische Explorationen
  14. The more attractive the more effective? Investigating the association of user experience and efficacy of an online and app-based gratitude intervention to reduce repetitive negative thinking
  15. 5th Producto Lifetimes and the Environment Conference (PLATE 2023): Gender roles as barriers to sustainable fashion lifetimes. How a deconstruction of norms can exted the use phase of garments.

Publikationen

  1. Gendered Energy – Analytische Perspektiven und Potenziale der Geschlechterforschung für eine sozial-ökologische Gestaltung der Energiewende im Raum
  2. A framework for drivers fostering social-ecological restoration within forest landscape based on people’s participation. A systematic literature review
  3. Spatial interpretation of high-resolution environmental proxy data of the Middle Pleistocene Palaeolithic faunal kill site Schöningen 13 II-4, Germany
  4. Climate reporting quality following the recommendations of the task force on climate-related financial disclosures: A Focus on the German capital market
  5. Initial hazard screening for genotoxicity of photo-transformation products of ciprofloxacin by applying a combination of experimental and in-silico testing
  6. Spring barley performance benefits from simultaneous shallow straw incorporation and top dressing as revealed by rhizotrons with resealable sampling ports
  7. Efficacy and cost-effectiveness of guided and unguided internet- and mobile-based indicated transdiagnostic prevention of depression and anxiety (ICare Prevent)
  8. Comparative effectiveness of three versions of a stepped care model for insomnia differing in the amount of therapist support in internet-delivered treatment
  9. The role of organized publics in articulating the exnovation of fossil-fuel technologies for intra- and intergenerational energy justice in energy transitions
  10. „Es ist eher so, dass wir miteinander konkurrieren“: Außerschulische Bildungsprojekte für ‚Geflüchtete‘ im Kontext von ‚EU-Türkei-Deal‘ und New Educational Governance
  11. A literature review concerning the non-carbon-related environmental goals of the EU Taxonomy Regulation and the European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS)
  12. Assessing the environmental fate of S-metolachlor, its commercial product Mercantor Gold® and their photoproducts using a water-sediment test and in silico methods
  13. Naturschutzfachliche und naturschutzrechtliche Anforderungen im Gefolge der Ausdehnung des Raumordnungsregimes auf die deutsche ausschließliche Wirtschaftszone
  14. Contrasting temporal trends and relationships of total organic carbon, black carbon, and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in rural low-altitude and remote high-altitude lakes
  15. A multi-level assessment of changes in stakeholder constellations, interest and influence on ecosystem services under different landscape scenarios in southwestern Ethiopia
  16. Musikalische Auseinandersetzungen mit dem Nationalsozialismus. Eine Autoethnographie des Erinnerungsprojektes Sound in the Silence im ehemaligen Konzentrationslager Ravensbrück
  17. Performance of the Chemcatcher ® passive sampler when used to monitor 10 polar and semi-polar pesticides in 16 Central European streams, and comparison with two other sampling methods
  18. Evidence for the age and timing of environmental change associated with a Lower Palaeolithic site within the Middle Pleistocene Reinsdorf sequence of the Schöningen coal mine, Germany
  19. Der "fachdidaktische Code" der Lebenswelt- und/oder (?) Situationsorientierung in der fachdidaktischen Diskussion der sozialwissenschaftlichen Unterrichtsfächer sowie des Lernfeldkonzepts
  20. Agriculture and everyday realities on small farms – An entrepreneurial challenge to farmers between the desire for autonomy and a secure existence. Two examples from east and south-east Poland
  21. Entwicklung eines Konzeptes für ein Mikrosystem zur gleichzeitigen Messung und Bestimmung von Konzentrationen in 3-Komponentenmischungen anhand der Wasser-Ethanol-Saccharose Lösungen für die Qualitätssicherung
  22. Julian von Oppen: Flucht, Migration und pädagogische Organisationen. Zur Bedeutung von kultureller Differenz in der Sozialen Arbeit mit unbegleiteten minderjährigen Geflüchteten. Weinheim: Beltz Juventa 2018,204 Seiten; ISBN 978-3-7799-3840-8