Value Creation Architectures for the Circular Economy: A Make-or-Buy Analysis in the Smartphone Industry

Publikation: Arbeits- oder Diskussionspapiere und BerichteArbeits- oder Diskussionspapiere

Authors

Smartphones make intensive use of precious metals and so called conflict minerals in order to reach their high performance in a compact size. In recent times, sustainability challenges related to production, use and disposal of smartphones are increasingly a topic of public debate. Thus, established industry actors and newly emerging firms are driven to engage in more sustainable practices, such as sustainable sourcing of materials, maintenance services or take-back schemes for discarded mobile phones.
This working paper explores sustainability practices in the smartphone industry from the perspective of the circular economy (CE) and related strategies for slowing and closing resource loops. In order to analyze these new industry arrangements, transaction cost theory (TCT) and the related make-or-buy analysis is used to derive circular value architectures. Combining TCT with the concept of a CE is a novel research approach that enables the empirical analysis of relationships between focal actors (e.g. manufacturers) and newly emerging loop operators (e.g. repair and recycling organizations).
We explore five case studies which stem from the Innovation Network on Sustainable Smartphones (INaS) at Leuphana University of Lüneburg, a living lab in which practitioners, scientists and non-governmental organizations collaborate to develop solutions for circular smartphone production and consumption systems.
Our core findings are four generic circular value creation architectures (cVCAs) for closing the loops in a CE: 1) vertically integrated loops, 2) cooperative loop networks, 3) outsourcing to loop operators and 4) independent loop operators. This work thus provides evidence that circular economy activities do not necessarily have to be managed by focal actors in the value chain. Rather, circular practices can also be put forward by specialized loop operators or even independent actors such as repair shops.
Furthermore, evidence from the case studies suggests that asset specificity for circular practices increases for higher order CE-loops such as maintenance or reuse, therefore long-term partnerships between focal actors and loop operators or vertical integration of CE practices are beneficial strategies to reach a sophisticated CE. Similarly, circular practices that go beyond recycling require a strong motivation, either through integration in the focal firm’s quality commitment or through business model recognition. It is further suggested that the circular design of products and services could reduce necessary transaction costs and thus overall costs of a circular economy.
OriginalspracheEnglisch
ErscheinungsortLüneburg
VerlagCentre for Sustainability Management
Anzahl der Seiten48
ISBN (Print)978-3-942638-67-8
PublikationsstatusErschienen - 2017

Zuletzt angesehen

Publikationen

  1. Degradation of β-blockers in hospital wastewater by means of ozonation and Fe2+/ozonation
  2. RIGID PRICES AS A RESULT FROM PROFIT MAXIMIZATION
  3. Crown size-growth relationships of European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) are driven by the interplay of disturbance intensity and inter-specific competition
  4. Internet der Dinge
  5. The path biography methodology
  6. The science-policy interface on ecosystems and people
  7. Risky Business
  8. “We cannot let this happen again”
  9. Politics after Networks
  10. Uniting against a common enemy
  11. Workplace mediation: Lessons from negotiation theory
  12. Quantifying the mitigation of temperature extremes by forests and wetlands in a temperate landscape
  13. Organisation
  14. Start-up Consulting in the German Language Realm
  15. Play as a creative misuse
  16. Es geht nicht um einen Dialog
  17. Does sustainable intensification offer a pathway to improved food security for aquatic agricultural system-dependent communities?
  18. Temporary organizing and acceleration
  19. Teachers’ assessment competence
  20. Credit Constraints and Exports
  21. Trajnostni razvoj v predsolskih ustanovah -
  22. The end of welfare as we know it?
  23. Developing sustainable business experimentation capability – A case study
  24. Aufbruch in eine andere Welt
  25. Text technology
  26. Assessing nature’s contributions to people
  27. Riskante Übergänge
  28. Fazit
  29. NePAD und der African Peer Review Mechanism
  30. Advanced ice-clamping control in the context of Industry 4.0
  31. Das Datenhandeln
  32. Street Wisdom
  33. Rechtskonformität
  34. Bad Practices in Unternehmen und die Mechanismen ihrer Etablierung
  35. Voltammetric studies of extruded pure magnesium in different electrolytes and its corrosion morphology
  36. Defining and reorienting competencies for sustainable global change
  37. Public Viewing
  38. From Blue Collar to Open Commons Region
  39. § 32 Republik Lettland
  40. The drawback of getting by-implicit imbalances in the educational support of young people in and leaving care in Germany
  41. Pete Rock
  42. Democratization
  43. Achieving high mechanical performance of the large-scale sand-casting Mg–4Y–x nd–y Gd–0.4Zr alloys by tailoring Nd and Gd contents
  44. cis-tris-σ homobenzenes from cis-benzenetrioxide
  45. Frankfurter Auschwitz-Prozess