Managers’ incentives and disincentives to engage with integrated reporting or why managers might not adopt integrated reporting: an exploratory study in a nascent setting

Publikation: Beiträge in ZeitschriftenZeitschriftenaufsätzeForschungbegutachtet

Standard

Harvard

APA

Vancouver

Bibtex

@article{473a7676379f430590140bf202578826,
title = "Managers{\textquoteright} incentives and disincentives to engage with integrated reporting or why managers might not adopt integrated reporting: an exploratory study in a nascent setting",
abstract = "Purpose: Despite its envisaged benefits, integrated reporting (IR) has yet to achieve its “breakthrough”, especially among small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). This study aims to discern SME leaders{\textquoteright} attitudes toward IR, and thereby to reveal managerial perceptions of both the potential benefits and the challenges that actually prevent them from embarking on IR. Design/methodology/approach: This explorative study is grounded on semi-structured interviews with 16 managers of large German SMEs, which yet do not apply IR but are potential candidates to implement it in the future. The engagement with non-preparers is expected to paint a more representative picture of actual reasons for IR (dis-)engagement compared to prior studies that address the few firms that have adopted IR and overcome its challenges. Applying Brown and Fraser{\textquoteright}s (2006) conceptual landscape, results are presented analogous to a business case-, stakeholder accountability- and critical theory dimension. Findings: Contrary to prior studies, which identified stakeholder accountability endeavors as kindling SME managers{\textquoteright} interest in voluntary reporting initiatives, managers regard IR primarily as a business case, serving to achieve legitimacy, improve corporate image, reach out to professional investors and assist in employee recruitment. However, they refrained from actually adopting the novel reporting medium, which suggests that decision-makers might not believe the business case to be as unproblematic as claimed by the proponents of IR. This was traced back to three major impediments that currently inhibit SMEs from reporting in an integrated way, namely, a perceived lack of interest by the relevant publics, infeasibility of the IR concept to meet user needs and preparation costs. These drawbacks resemble those of earlier voluntary reporting experiments, calling into question the “revolutionary” character of IR. The study critically concludes that the future development of IR depends on addressing these barriers. Originality/value: To the best of the author{\textquoteright}s knowledge, this is the first explorative study to deliberately engage with IR non-preparers to draw conclusions on impediments to IR. The identification of relevant incentives and disincentives for IR among SME managers at first hand not only adds to the small extant IR research body and provides valuable insights for research, practice and standard setting but also contributes to the contemporary debate about dominant legitimacy-based explanations in the broader domain of social and environmental accounting and reporting.",
keywords = "Integrated reporting, Legitimacy, Managers, Motives and challenges, Small- and medium-sized enterprises, Social and environmental accounting and reporting (SEAR), Management studies",
author = "Jannik Gerwanski",
year = "2020",
month = oct,
day = "15",
doi = "10.1108/QRAM-01-2019-0025",
language = "English",
volume = "17",
pages = "553--587",
journal = "Qualitative Research in Accounting & Management",
issn = "1176-6093",
publisher = "Emerald Publishing Limited",
number = "4",

}

RIS

TY - JOUR

T1 - Managers’ incentives and disincentives to engage with integrated reporting or why managers might not adopt integrated reporting

T2 - an exploratory study in a nascent setting

AU - Gerwanski, Jannik

PY - 2020/10/15

Y1 - 2020/10/15

N2 - Purpose: Despite its envisaged benefits, integrated reporting (IR) has yet to achieve its “breakthrough”, especially among small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). This study aims to discern SME leaders’ attitudes toward IR, and thereby to reveal managerial perceptions of both the potential benefits and the challenges that actually prevent them from embarking on IR. Design/methodology/approach: This explorative study is grounded on semi-structured interviews with 16 managers of large German SMEs, which yet do not apply IR but are potential candidates to implement it in the future. The engagement with non-preparers is expected to paint a more representative picture of actual reasons for IR (dis-)engagement compared to prior studies that address the few firms that have adopted IR and overcome its challenges. Applying Brown and Fraser’s (2006) conceptual landscape, results are presented analogous to a business case-, stakeholder accountability- and critical theory dimension. Findings: Contrary to prior studies, which identified stakeholder accountability endeavors as kindling SME managers’ interest in voluntary reporting initiatives, managers regard IR primarily as a business case, serving to achieve legitimacy, improve corporate image, reach out to professional investors and assist in employee recruitment. However, they refrained from actually adopting the novel reporting medium, which suggests that decision-makers might not believe the business case to be as unproblematic as claimed by the proponents of IR. This was traced back to three major impediments that currently inhibit SMEs from reporting in an integrated way, namely, a perceived lack of interest by the relevant publics, infeasibility of the IR concept to meet user needs and preparation costs. These drawbacks resemble those of earlier voluntary reporting experiments, calling into question the “revolutionary” character of IR. The study critically concludes that the future development of IR depends on addressing these barriers. Originality/value: To the best of the author’s knowledge, this is the first explorative study to deliberately engage with IR non-preparers to draw conclusions on impediments to IR. The identification of relevant incentives and disincentives for IR among SME managers at first hand not only adds to the small extant IR research body and provides valuable insights for research, practice and standard setting but also contributes to the contemporary debate about dominant legitimacy-based explanations in the broader domain of social and environmental accounting and reporting.

AB - Purpose: Despite its envisaged benefits, integrated reporting (IR) has yet to achieve its “breakthrough”, especially among small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). This study aims to discern SME leaders’ attitudes toward IR, and thereby to reveal managerial perceptions of both the potential benefits and the challenges that actually prevent them from embarking on IR. Design/methodology/approach: This explorative study is grounded on semi-structured interviews with 16 managers of large German SMEs, which yet do not apply IR but are potential candidates to implement it in the future. The engagement with non-preparers is expected to paint a more representative picture of actual reasons for IR (dis-)engagement compared to prior studies that address the few firms that have adopted IR and overcome its challenges. Applying Brown and Fraser’s (2006) conceptual landscape, results are presented analogous to a business case-, stakeholder accountability- and critical theory dimension. Findings: Contrary to prior studies, which identified stakeholder accountability endeavors as kindling SME managers’ interest in voluntary reporting initiatives, managers regard IR primarily as a business case, serving to achieve legitimacy, improve corporate image, reach out to professional investors and assist in employee recruitment. However, they refrained from actually adopting the novel reporting medium, which suggests that decision-makers might not believe the business case to be as unproblematic as claimed by the proponents of IR. This was traced back to three major impediments that currently inhibit SMEs from reporting in an integrated way, namely, a perceived lack of interest by the relevant publics, infeasibility of the IR concept to meet user needs and preparation costs. These drawbacks resemble those of earlier voluntary reporting experiments, calling into question the “revolutionary” character of IR. The study critically concludes that the future development of IR depends on addressing these barriers. Originality/value: To the best of the author’s knowledge, this is the first explorative study to deliberately engage with IR non-preparers to draw conclusions on impediments to IR. The identification of relevant incentives and disincentives for IR among SME managers at first hand not only adds to the small extant IR research body and provides valuable insights for research, practice and standard setting but also contributes to the contemporary debate about dominant legitimacy-based explanations in the broader domain of social and environmental accounting and reporting.

KW - Integrated reporting

KW - Legitimacy

KW - Managers

KW - Motives and challenges

KW - Small- and medium-sized enterprises

KW - Social and environmental accounting and reporting (SEAR)

KW - Management studies

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85089996728&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1108/QRAM-01-2019-0025

DO - 10.1108/QRAM-01-2019-0025

M3 - Journal articles

AN - SCOPUS:85089996728

VL - 17

SP - 553

EP - 587

JO - Qualitative Research in Accounting & Management

JF - Qualitative Research in Accounting & Management

SN - 1176-6093

IS - 4

ER -

DOI

Zuletzt angesehen

Aktivitäten

  1. Fostering inter-institutional Development Teams in ITE & School Practice: The Significance of epistemic, social and organisational integration.
  2. Zur Bedeutung epistemischer, sozialer und organisationaler Integration für die institutionenübergreifende Entwicklungsteamarbeit im ZZL-Netzwerk
  3. Changing learning environments at university? Comparing the learning strategies of non-traditional European students engaged in lifelong learning.
  4. Netzwerkbasierte Analysen In der Unterrichtsforschung - Potentiale & Herausforderungen für die Erfassung und Beschreibung von Interaktionsprozessen
  5. Strategies in Communicating the Change Vision: How Power Distance-Orientation Maderates Recipients'Reactions towards Change Communication Strategies
  6. Effekte einer freiwilligen Mitgliedschaft in Berufsverbänden auf das Einkommen - Eine Analyse der Einkommensdynamik bei Freiberuflern in Deutschland
  7. What is in the attention of pre-service teachers while teaching? An eye-tracking study about attention processes during standardized teaching situations
  8. Lerner*innensprache, Fachsprache, Agency – Digitale Lerner*innentexte in transdisziplinärenNachhaltigkeitsdiskursen im projektbasierten Englischunterricht
  9. Zum Verhältnis von Reflexionskompetenz und Beliefs für inklusiven Fremdsprachenunterricht: Empirische Erkenntnisse und fortbildungsdidaktische Settings
  10. ‚Systemische Visualisierung‘ als Lernmethode zur Reflexion wirtschaftsbetrieblicher Situationen im Kontext der Großen Transformation zur Nachhaltigkeit
  11. Effects of an Internet-based guided self-help intervention for college women with eating disorders: Long-term results from a large randomized controlled trial.
  12. „Papa, jetzt haben wir selbst in Mathe noch Geografie!” - Das Potential von Karten für die Fachdidaktische Forschung und den Geometrieunterricht der Grundschule
  13. „Papa, jetzt haben wir selbst in Mathe noch Geografie!” - Das Potential von Karten für die Fachdidaktische Forschung und DEN GEOMETRIEUNTERRICHT DER GRUNDSCHULE
  14. Implementing an Internet-based platform for eating disorder screening, prevention, and treatment on college campuses: Preliminary results from a state-wide initiative.
  15. Entwicklungsteam Mathematik - Einblick in die Arbeit einer Community of Practice zur Weiterentwicklung von Lehrkräfteprofessionalität im mathematischen Problemlösen

Publikationen

  1. Internationalisierung von kleinen und mittelständischen Unternehmen (KMU) – Herausforderungen für das mittelständische Personalmanagement
  2. Entwicklung eines Lehrkonzepts zur Implementierung von Medien für einen digital-gestützten Deutschunterricht im berufsbildenden Lehramt
  3. Personalization strategies in digital mental health interventions: a systematic review and conceptual framework for depressive symptoms
  4. Risk or Resilience? The Role of Trade Integration and Foreign Ownership for the Survival of German Enterprises during the Crisis 2008-2010
  5. Does elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide affect internal nitrogen allocation in the temperate trees Alnus glutinosa and Pinus sylvestris?
  6. Tensegrität - lebendige Balance in den Führungstrukturen von Unternehmen und ihre Bedeutung für den unternehmerischen Entscheidungsprozess
  7. Taking a Behavioral Science Approach to Understand Blood Donation Behavior – Empirical Evidence and Implications for Blood Donor Marketing
  8. Visualisierte Empfindung und verkörperte Wahrnehmung. Julius Meier-Graefe und die anthropologischen Konturen seiner kunstkritischen Praxis
  9. Ist die Einschränkung der Erbschaftsteuerfreiheit einer Zugewinnausgleichsforderung gemäß § 5 Abs. 1 Satz 2 und 4 ErbStG verfassungswidrig?
  10. Wie unterscheiden sich Familien in Bezug auf naturwissenschaftliche Anregungen im Vorschulalter? Familiäre Disparitäten im Elementarbereich
  11. Correction to: Metallurgical aspects of joining commercially pure titanium to Ti-6Al-4V alloy in a T-joint configuration by laser beam welding
  12. Cross-case knowledge transfer in transformative research: enabling learning in and across sustainability-oriented labs through case reporting
  13. Ein kognitives, häusliches Diagnosesystem für kardiovaskuläre Erkrankungen auf Basis probabilistischer und beschreibungslogischer Verfahren
  14. Thermal cycling and creep studies of AM50+Nd magnesium alloy based carbon fiber, SiC particulate and IN-SITU Mg2Si reinforced hybrid composites
  15. Numerical Investigation of the Effect of Rolling on the Localized Stress and Strain Induction for Wire + Arc Additive Manufactured Structures
  16. Riding Two Horses at The Same Time: Paradox Responses for Navigating Exploration and Exploitation in Small and Medium-Sized IT Consulting Firms
  17. Mit Hilfe der Mathematik eine gute Entscheidung treffen — Förderung der Fähigkeit des kritischen Denkens als Bestandteil von „21st-Century-Skills“
  18. Michael May / Jessica Schattschneider (Hg.): Klassiker der Politikdidaktik neu gelesen. Originale und Kommentare. Schwalbach/Ts. 2011: Wochenschau Verlag.
  19. Multicolony tracking reveals potential threats to little auks wintering in the North Atlantic from marine pollution and shrinking sea ice cover
  20. Zum Spannungsfeld der Öffnung und Schließung von Unternehmensgrenzen. Eine ressourcenorientierte Perspektive am Beispiel von Projektnetzwerken
  21. Generative KI wie ChatGPT und Learning Analytics im Zusammenspiel: Ein ko-kreatives Anwendungsszenario zur Entwicklung didaktischer Lernmaterialien.
  22. What enables metals ‘being’ ‘responsible’? An exploratory study on the enabling of organizational identity claims through a new sustainability standard
  23. How does green suit me? Consumers mentally match perceived product attributes with their domain-specific motives when making green purchase decisions
  24. A framework for drivers fostering social-ecological restoration within forest landscape based on people’s participation. A systematic literature review
  25. Reconciling Scientific, Political and Participatory Perspectives on Sustainable Tourism Indicator Development for Destination Sustainability Assessment
  26. The impact of auditor rotation, audit firm rotation and non-audit services on earnings quality, audit quality and investor perceptions: A literature review
  27. Barley (Hordeum distichon L.) roots produce volatile aldehydes derived from the lipoxygenase/hydroperoxide lyase pathway with a strong age-dependent pattern
  28. Lessons from visualising the landscape and habitat implications of tree decline-and its remediation through tree planting-in Australia's grazing landscapes
  29. Experimentally validated multi-step simulation strategy to predict the fatigue crack propagation rate in residual stress fields after laser shock peening
  30. Spring barley performance benefits from simultaneous shallow straw incorporation and top dressing as revealed by rhizotrons with resealable sampling ports
  31. Entwicklung eines Verfahrens zur Darstellung der Transmittanz von bündelführenden optischen Komponenten unter spezieller Berücksichtigung der Polarisation
  32. Numerical responses of saproxylic beetles to rapid increases in dead wood availability following geometrid moth outbreaks in sub-arctic mountain birch forest
  33. A temporal analysis of how entrepreneurial goal intentions, positive fantasies, and action planning affect starting a new venture and when the effects wear off.
  34. Where Tasks, Technology, and Textbooks Meet: An Exploratory Analysis of English Language Teachers’ Perceived Affordances of an Intelligent Language Tutoring System