The patterns of curriculum change processes that embed sustainability in higher education institutions

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Standard

The patterns of curriculum change processes that embed sustainability in higher education institutions. / Weiss, Marie; Barth, Matthias; von Wehrden, Henrik.
In: Sustainability Science, Vol. 16, No. 5, 01.09.2021, p. 1579-1593.

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Harvard

APA

Vancouver

Bibtex

@article{3728026cbe434af8a87fe08b6da90fdf,
title = "The patterns of curriculum change processes that embed sustainability in higher education institutions",
abstract = "Implementing education for sustainable development (ESD) in higher education institutions (HEIs) is critical to facilitating a transition toward sustainable development. However, little is known about the specific implementation processes that lead to the institutionalization of sustainability curricula in HEIs. This meta-study and cluster analysis uses 131 international case studies to shed light on six distinct implementation patterns: (1) collaborative paradigm change, (2) bottom-up, evolving institutional change, (3) top-down, mandated institutional change, (4) externally driven initiatives, (5) isolated initiatives, and (6) limited institutional change. A cluster comparison reveals two distinct implementation phases: ESD can be implemented from the bottom-up, from the top-down, or both, and the impetus can stem from manifold external or internal stakeholders. To achieve more comprehensive ESD implementation, open communication among all stakeholders should be facilitated and feedback as well as reflection encouraged. Maintaining a unified vision statement and active participation of all stakeholders fosters a sense of ownership in ESD implementation and ensures that it will be long-lasting. Collaboration between isolated ESD initiatives and various stakeholders leads to shared knowledge and resources. Strong informal collaboration and communication can compensate for a lack of formalized leadership support from the top. Moreover, thorough planning that involves creating a strategy with detailed steps, and balancing shared responsibilities among internal stakeholders further enables fuller implementation of ESD. This analysis represents a first synthesis of small-N case studies and facilitates a better understanding of sustainability curriculum implementation patterns, which are shared in different contexts. Most HEIs and practitioners can benefit from these findings by reflecting on the specific implementation pattern with which the most overlap is found and focusing on this pattern{\textquoteright}s most pertinent drivers.",
keywords = "Curriculum change, Education for sustainable development, Higher education, Implementation pattern, Meta-analysis, Universities, Sustainability education, Didactics of elementary social studies and science",
author = "Marie Weiss and Matthias Barth and {von Wehrden}, Henrik",
note = "The authors gratefully acknowledge funding from the Lower Saxony Ministry of Science and Culture and the Volkswagen Foundation for the grant “Educating Future Change Agents—Higher Education as a Motor of the Sustainability Transformation” (A115235) through the program “Science for Sustainable Development.” We also wish to thank our research- and student assistants Anna Falkenstein, Franziska Steinbr{\"u}gge, Johanna Kruse, and Lisa Eberhardt for their support in coding the cases and carrying out an inter-rater agreement test. Additional thanks are due to the whole EFCA research team—especially to Arnim Wiek, Jana Timm, Jodie Birdman, and Aaron Redman—for developing the entire EFCA analytical scheme (code book) and for their helpful comments during the various phases of its development. Furthermore, we gratefully acknowledge the reviewers{\textquoteright} valuable comments, which helped to improve this article. ",
year = "2021",
month = sep,
day = "1",
doi = "10.1007/s11625-021-00984-1",
language = "English",
volume = "16",
pages = "1579--1593",
journal = "Sustainability Science",
issn = "1862-4065",
publisher = "Springer",
number = "5",

}

RIS

TY - JOUR

T1 - The patterns of curriculum change processes that embed sustainability in higher education institutions

AU - Weiss, Marie

AU - Barth, Matthias

AU - von Wehrden, Henrik

N1 - The authors gratefully acknowledge funding from the Lower Saxony Ministry of Science and Culture and the Volkswagen Foundation for the grant “Educating Future Change Agents—Higher Education as a Motor of the Sustainability Transformation” (A115235) through the program “Science for Sustainable Development.” We also wish to thank our research- and student assistants Anna Falkenstein, Franziska Steinbrügge, Johanna Kruse, and Lisa Eberhardt for their support in coding the cases and carrying out an inter-rater agreement test. Additional thanks are due to the whole EFCA research team—especially to Arnim Wiek, Jana Timm, Jodie Birdman, and Aaron Redman—for developing the entire EFCA analytical scheme (code book) and for their helpful comments during the various phases of its development. Furthermore, we gratefully acknowledge the reviewers’ valuable comments, which helped to improve this article.

PY - 2021/9/1

Y1 - 2021/9/1

N2 - Implementing education for sustainable development (ESD) in higher education institutions (HEIs) is critical to facilitating a transition toward sustainable development. However, little is known about the specific implementation processes that lead to the institutionalization of sustainability curricula in HEIs. This meta-study and cluster analysis uses 131 international case studies to shed light on six distinct implementation patterns: (1) collaborative paradigm change, (2) bottom-up, evolving institutional change, (3) top-down, mandated institutional change, (4) externally driven initiatives, (5) isolated initiatives, and (6) limited institutional change. A cluster comparison reveals two distinct implementation phases: ESD can be implemented from the bottom-up, from the top-down, or both, and the impetus can stem from manifold external or internal stakeholders. To achieve more comprehensive ESD implementation, open communication among all stakeholders should be facilitated and feedback as well as reflection encouraged. Maintaining a unified vision statement and active participation of all stakeholders fosters a sense of ownership in ESD implementation and ensures that it will be long-lasting. Collaboration between isolated ESD initiatives and various stakeholders leads to shared knowledge and resources. Strong informal collaboration and communication can compensate for a lack of formalized leadership support from the top. Moreover, thorough planning that involves creating a strategy with detailed steps, and balancing shared responsibilities among internal stakeholders further enables fuller implementation of ESD. This analysis represents a first synthesis of small-N case studies and facilitates a better understanding of sustainability curriculum implementation patterns, which are shared in different contexts. Most HEIs and practitioners can benefit from these findings by reflecting on the specific implementation pattern with which the most overlap is found and focusing on this pattern’s most pertinent drivers.

AB - Implementing education for sustainable development (ESD) in higher education institutions (HEIs) is critical to facilitating a transition toward sustainable development. However, little is known about the specific implementation processes that lead to the institutionalization of sustainability curricula in HEIs. This meta-study and cluster analysis uses 131 international case studies to shed light on six distinct implementation patterns: (1) collaborative paradigm change, (2) bottom-up, evolving institutional change, (3) top-down, mandated institutional change, (4) externally driven initiatives, (5) isolated initiatives, and (6) limited institutional change. A cluster comparison reveals two distinct implementation phases: ESD can be implemented from the bottom-up, from the top-down, or both, and the impetus can stem from manifold external or internal stakeholders. To achieve more comprehensive ESD implementation, open communication among all stakeholders should be facilitated and feedback as well as reflection encouraged. Maintaining a unified vision statement and active participation of all stakeholders fosters a sense of ownership in ESD implementation and ensures that it will be long-lasting. Collaboration between isolated ESD initiatives and various stakeholders leads to shared knowledge and resources. Strong informal collaboration and communication can compensate for a lack of formalized leadership support from the top. Moreover, thorough planning that involves creating a strategy with detailed steps, and balancing shared responsibilities among internal stakeholders further enables fuller implementation of ESD. This analysis represents a first synthesis of small-N case studies and facilitates a better understanding of sustainability curriculum implementation patterns, which are shared in different contexts. Most HEIs and practitioners can benefit from these findings by reflecting on the specific implementation pattern with which the most overlap is found and focusing on this pattern’s most pertinent drivers.

KW - Curriculum change

KW - Education for sustainable development

KW - Higher education

KW - Implementation pattern

KW - Meta-analysis

KW - Universities

KW - Sustainability education

KW - Didactics of elementary social studies and science

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85108224267&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s11625-021-00984-1

DO - 10.1007/s11625-021-00984-1

M3 - Journal articles

AN - SCOPUS:85108224267

VL - 16

SP - 1579

EP - 1593

JO - Sustainability Science

JF - Sustainability Science

SN - 1862-4065

IS - 5

ER -

Documents

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Ein Verfahren zur vergleichenden Analyse mündlicher Sprachproben von DaZ-Schüler/-innen: zur Kategorienentwicklung
  2. Video analysis in Design-Based Research – Findings of a project on self-organised learning at a vocational school
  3. Öffentlichkeit als epistemologische und politische Ressource für die Genese umstrittener Wissenschaftskonzepte
  4. Double perspective taking processes of primary children - adoption and application of a psychological instrument
  5. Überlegungen und erste Erfahrungen zur Förderung mathematisch interessierter Grundschüler - die "Matheasse" in Jena
  6. 'You are angels': understanding the entanglement of family and enterprise in an early-stage family-run coworking space
  7. Geschäftsmodell für regionale Direktvermarktung von Strom in einer Modellregion am Beispiel von Greenpeace Energy
  8. Darstellung der Referenzarbeit: Schmidt, Torben (2007). Gemeinsames Lernen mit Selbstlernsoftware im Englischunterricht
  9. Temporal dynamics of conflict monitoring and the effects of one or two conflict sources on error-(related) negativity
  10. (Inhibiting) Factors for (Un)Sustainable Behaviour in Relation to the Effects of Education for Sustainable Development
  11. Fehlende Daten bei Unterrichtsbeobachtungen: Eine Sensitivitätsanalyse anhand von Daten der Schulinspektion Hamburg.
  12. Kooperationsaufgaben von Stützlehrern im Spannungsfeld von Professionalisierung und strukturellen Rahmenbedingungen
  13. Die Entwicklung von bildungswissenschaftlichem Wissen: Theoretischer Rahmen, Testinstrument, Skalierung und Ergebnisse
  14. Interaction-Dominant Causation in Mind and Brain, and Its Implication for Questions of Generalization and Replication
  15. Jahreszeitliche Veränderungen der Trockenwetterganglinie - Fallstudie für einen Fluss im europäischen Teil der Türkei
  16. Remobilisierung von Quecksilber durch Desinfektionsmittel aus Amalgamabscheidern zahnärztlicher Behandlungseinheiten
  17. Lena Kugler: Die Zeit der Tiere. Zur Polychronie und Biodiversität der Moderne, Konstanz: Konstanz University Press 2021
  18. Score-informed tracking and contextual analysis of fundamental frequency contours in trumpet and saxophone jazz solos
  19. Gesundheit und Gesundheitsversorgung von Menschen in der aufenthaltsrechtlichen Illegalität in Deutschland und Italien
  20. Ausgestaltungsmöglichkeiten umweltpolitischer Instrumente zur Förderung ökologisch vorteilhafter Getränkeverpackungen
  21. Sozioökonomische Analyse von Pflegemaßnahmen zur Erhaltung von Heidelandschaften im Naturschutzgebiet Lüneburger Heide
  22. Hochwasser- und Küstenschutz unter Klimawandelbedingungen als besonderes Aufgabengebiet von Partizipation und Kooperation
  23. Othering and Same-ing for the Young. Expanding the Theoretical and Material Horizons of Imagology with Children's Literature