Reviewing the science on 50 years of conservation: Knowledge production biases and lessons for practice

Research output: Journal contributionsScientific review articlesResearch

Authors

  • Neil M. Dawson
  • Brendan Coolsaet
  • Aditi Bhardwaj
  • David Brown
  • Bosco Lliso
  • Jacqueline Loos
  • Laura Mannocci
  • Adrian Martin
  • Malena Oliva
  • Unai Pascual
  • Pasang Sherpa
  • Thomas Worsdell

Drawing on 662 studies from 102 countries, we present a systematic review of published empirical studies about site-level biodiversity conservation initiated between 1970 and 2019. Within this sample, we find that knowledge production about the Global South is largely produced by researchers in the Global North, implying a neocolonial power dynamic. We also find evidence of bias in reported ecological outcomes linked to lack of independence in scientific studies, serving to uphold narratives about who should lead conservation. We explore relationships in the sample studies between conservation initiative types, the extent of Indigenous Peoples’ and local communities’ influence in governance, and reported social and ecological outcomes. Findings reveal positive ecological and social outcomes are strongly associated with higher levels of influence of Indigenous Peoples and local communities and their institutions, implying equity in conservation practice should be advanced not only for moral reasons, but because it can enhance conservation effectiveness.

Original languageEnglish
JournalAmbio
Volume53
Issue number10
Pages (from-to)1395-1413
Number of pages19
ISSN0044-7447
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 10.2024

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© The Author(s) 2024.

    Research areas

  • Conservation effectiveness, Conservation science, Equitable governance, Indigenous Peoples and local communities, Participation, Rights-based conservation
  • Biology
  • Ecosystems Research

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. ‘Kollegah the Boss’
  2. Breaching the campus
  3. Predicting individual plant performance in grasslands
  4. Society and territory
  5. Rezension zu "Sonia Delaunay - Mode und Design"
  6. #3 Unstable Infrastructures
  7. USA - Südwesten
  8. Driving anger expression in Germany—Validation of the Driving Anger Expression Inventory for German drivers
  9. Simulationsbasierte Optimierung des Umgangs mit Chef-Aufträgen im Produktionsbetrieb
  10. Invertebrate herbivory rather than competition with tussocks will increasingly delay highland forest regeneration in degraded areas under active restoration
  11. Barriers to a sustainability transformation of meat production practices - An industry actor perspective
  12. § 33 Solare Strahlungsenergie an oder auf Gebäuden
  13. Central bank announcements
  14. Multiple goal pursuit
  15. Capitalism with a Transhuman Face
  16. Institutional Logics as orchestras' strategic dilemma
  17. Editoral
  18. Selbstreguliertes Lesen von Texten
  19. Der Himbeerwurm
  20. Ehrliche Erfindungen
  21. Biopolitical bordering
  22. Does pictorial composition guide the eye? Investigating four centuries of last supper pictures
  23. Erfolgreich promovieren in den Ingenieurwissenschaften
  24. Bewertung der Nachhaltigkeit von Software: Entwicklung einer Umweltkennzeichnung
  25. Personality-based selection of entrepreneurial borrowers to reduce credit risk
  26. Irreversibility, ignorance, and the intergenerational equity-efficieny trade-off
  27. Influence of family presence on expatriate outcomes
  28. Analyse menschlicher Fehlerursachen im OP-Saal
  29. Species from different taxonomic groups show similar invasion traits
  30. Futurizing politics and the sustainability of real-world experiments
  31. Multikonferenz Wirtschaftsinformatik 2018
  32. First record of Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis on amphibians in Romania
  33. Kittler
  34. Psychological interventions to prevent the onset of major depression in adults
  35. Qualifikation zur Lehrkraft für Sozialpädagogik
  36. Kunst und Globalisierung
  37. Land sparing versus land sharing
  38. The age of the hominin fossils from Jebel Irhoud, Morocco, and the origins of the Middle Stone Age
  39. Wissensaustausch im digitalen Arbeitsumfeld
  40. Reputation und Reiseentscheidung im Internet