Principles for the application of life cycle sustainability assessment

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Sonia Valdivia
  • Jana Gerta Backes
  • Marzia Traverso
  • Guido Sonnemann
  • Stefano Cucurachi
  • Jeroen B. Guinée
  • Thomas Schaubroeck
  • Matthias Finkbeiner
  • Noemie Leroy-Parmentier
  • Cássia Ugaya
  • Claudia Peña
  • Alessandra Zamagni
  • Atsushi Inaba
  • Milena Amaral
  • Markus Berger
  • Jolanta Dvarioniene
  • Tatiana Vakhitova
  • Catherine Benoit-Norris
  • Martina Prox
  • Rajendra Foolmaun
  • And 1 others
  • Mark Goedkoop

Purpose and context: This paper aims to establish principles for the increased application and use of life cycle sustainability assessment (LCSA). Sustainable development (SD) encompassing resilient economies and social stability of the global system is growingly important for decision-makers from business and governments. The “17 SDGs” emerge as a high-level shared blueprint for peace, abundance, and prosperity for people and the planet, and “sustainability” for supporting improvements of products and organizations. A “sustainability” interpretation—successful in aligning stakeholders’ understanding—subdivides the impacts according to a triple bottom line or three pillars: economic, social, and environmental impacts. These context and urgent needs inspired the LCSA framework. This entails a sustainability assessment of products and organizations in accordance with the three pillars, while adopting a life cycle perspective. Methods: The Life Cycle Initiative promotes since 2011 a pragmatic LCSA framework based on the three techniques: LCSA = environmental life cycle assessment (LCA) + life cycle costing (LCC) + social life cycle assessment (S-LCA). This is the focus of the paper, while acknowledging previous developments. Identified and reviewed literature shows challenges of addressing the three pillars in the LCSA framework implementation like considering only two pillars; not being fully aligned with ISO 14040; lacking interconnectedness among the three pillars; not having clear criteria for results’ weighting nor clear results’ interpretation; and not following cause-effect chains and mechanisms leading to an endpoint. Agreement building among LCSA experts and reviewing processes strengthened the consensus on this paper. Broad support and outreach are ensured by publishing this as position paper. Results: For harmonizing practical LCSA applications, easing interpretation, and increasing usefulness, consensed ten LCSA principles (10P) are established: understanding the areas of protection, alignment with ISO 14040, completeness, stakeholders’ and product utility considerations, materiality of system boundaries, transparency, consistency, explicit trade-offs’ communication, and caution when compensating impacts. Examples were provided based on a fictional plastic water bottle Conclusions: In spite of increasing needs for and interest in SD and sustainability supporting tools, LCSA is at an early application stage of application. The 10P aim to promote more and better LCSA applications by ensuring alignment with ISO 14040, completeness and clear interpretation of integrated results, among others. For consolidating its use, however, more consensus-building is needed (e.g., on value-laden ethical aspects of LCSA, interdependencies and interconnectedness among the three dimensions, and harmonization and integration of the three techniques) and technical and policy recommendations for application.

Original languageEnglish
JournalInternational Journal of Life Cycle Assessment
Volume26
Issue number9
Pages (from-to)1900-1905
Number of pages6
ISSN0948-3349
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 09.2021

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© 2021, The Author(s).

Recently viewed

Researchers

  1. Aviva Brin

Publications

  1. Begriffsklärung: Symmetrie
  2. Arbeitszufriedenheit
  3. Flexible Arbeitszeiten
  4. Summer temperatures from the Middle Pleistocene site Schöningen 13 II, northern Germany, determined from subfossil chironomid assemblages
  5. Mela Hartwig: Ekstasen. Novellen
  6. Was hat uns bloß so ruiniert?
  7. Wirtschaftsinformatik in wirtschaftswissenschaftlichen Studiengängen an Fachhochschulen
  8. Process Development for Wire-based Laser Metal Deposition of 5087 Aluminium alloy by using Fibre Laser
  9. "Glück malt man mit Punkten, Unglück mit Strichen"
  10. Social assessment and management of conflict minerals
  11. Between Fostering and Outsourcing Educational Justice: The EU-Turkey Statement and its Impacts on the Education of "Refugee Students" in Turkey
  12. Complexities and Nuances in Radical Right Voters' (Anti)Feminism
  13. § 328 Beschränkung der Rechte
  14. Rethinking AI
  15. An extended kalman filter for time delays inspired by a fractional order model
  16. Falling “fortresses”
  17. The Stakes of the Stage
  18. Evaluation of the OECD P OV and LRTP screening tool for estimating the long-range transport of organophosphate esters
  19. Obdachlosigkeit und Wohnungsnot unter weiblichem Blickwinkel
  20. Functional flower traits and their diversity drive pollinator visitation
  21. Internetgestützte Nachhaltigkeitsberichterstattung
  22. Kinderliterarisches Übersetzen
  23. Exploring teachers' mental health literacy: An exploratory study on teachers' experiences, cooperation partners, self-efficacy, and knowledge related to students' mental health problems
  24. Education for Sustainable Development Goals
  25. The day after mowing: Time and type of mowing influence grassland arthropods
  26. Shifting alliances: The radicalization of Sweden's mainstream right and implications for (social) democracy
  27. Editorial overview: Selected articles from green and sustainable chemistry conference
  28. Berufsprofile in der IT-Beratung
  29. Screening for Start-up Potential in Universities and Research Institutions - Or How to Map Invisible Innovation Potentials.
  30. Offene Fragen
  31. Mittelstand 2008
  32. Leading and Influencing in Organisations
  33. Meaning making in cancer survivors
  34. Defaunation through the eyes of the Tsimane’
  35. Crossing borders
  36. Stirbt Daily Mail langsam?
  37. Least-Cost Transportation Planning - Eine Konzeptidee
  38. Unraveling the relationship between presidential approval and the economy
  39. Single mothers figuring out their future family life – understanding family development after separation and divorce drawing upon the concept of configuration
  40. MediaArtHistories, ed. by Oliver Grau
  41. The role of belief in a just world for (dis)honest behavior
  42. § 395: Verschwiegensheitspflicht
  43. Arendt i Kant: ravnopravni drugi i “prosireni nacin misljenja“ (Arendt and Kant: the Equal Others and an “Extended Way of Thinking”)
  44. Trembling Time
  45. Jacobi-Otto-Diesel
  46. The contagion effect of environmental violations