Participation in River Basin Planning Under the Water Framework Directive – Has it Benefitted Good Water Status?

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

The participation of societal groups and of the broader public has been a key feature in implementing the European Water Framework Directive (WFD). Non-state actor participation in the drafting of river basin management plans was expected to help achieve the directive’s environmental goals, but the recent literature leaves us doubtful whether this has in fact been the case. This study examines a structured online survey of 118 public water managers, covering the six biggest European Union states ofFrance, Germany, Italy, Poland, Spain and the UK. We assess multiple facets of participation, for example the involved actors, the intensity of communication exchange, and participants’ influence on planning. Results show that participatory WFD implementation has included a wide range of actor groups but rarely citizens, and that there has been minimal provision for interactive communication. The value of active involvement to the reaching of environmental goals was assessed as limited and that of public consultation as insignificant. Participants who were actively involved mainly contributed by advocating for stronger environmental standards and by providing implementation-relevant knowledge. Potential reasons for the overall poor record of participation include the strong influence of agriculture and the lack of public interest. Our findings suggest that, in hindsight, the European Commission’s conviction that participation benefits good water status appears overly naïve.
Original languageEnglish
JournalWater Alternatives
Volume13
Issue number3
Pages (from-to)484-512
Number of pages29
ISSN1965-0175
Publication statusPublished - 01.10.2020

    Research areas

  • Environmental Governance - active involvement, river basin management, ecological outcomes, mandated participatory planning, European water governance, participatory governance, stakeholder involvement

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Der einsatz von lernstrategien in einer konkreten lernsituation bei schülern unterschiedlicher jahrgangsstufen
  2. Advantages and Disadvanteges of Different Text Coding Procedures for Research and Practice in a School Context
  3. Stellvertretung als allgemeines Rechtsinstitut - zu Theorie, Dogmatik und Reichweite des Repräsentationsprinzips
  4. Zur Bedeutung der Selbstwirksamkeit für eine individuelle Förderung im Unterricht mit heterogenen Lerngruppen
  5. School leaders’ innovation-related self-efficacy: professional development and learning networks make a difference
  6. La competencia intercultural y la competencia pragmática en la enseñanza de español como lengua extranjera (ELE)
  7. A multivariate, multilevel analysis of the relationship between cognitive abilities and scholastic achievement
  8. Social organization influences the exchange and species richness of medicinal plants in amazonian homegardens
  9. Training im Sportunterricht – sport- und trainingspädagogische Zugänge sowie methodisch-didaktische Überlegungen
  10. Why is there not more demand for redistribution? Cross-national evidence for the role of social justice beliefs
  11. A sufficient asymptotic stability condition in generalised model predictive control to avoid input saturation
  12. Inversion of Fuzzy Neural Networks for the Reduction of Noise in the Control Loop for Automotive Applications
  13. Resonating self-tracking practices? Empirical insights into theoretical reflections on a 'sociology of resonance'
  14. On the Problems of Honorary Work in German Sports Clubs – A Qualitative-Dominated Crossover Mixed Methods Study
  15. Socio-demographic factors, entrepreneurial orientation, personal initiative, and environmental problems in Uganda
  16. Nanomechanical Analysis and Fractography of Extruded Mg-Dy-Nd Based Alloy Influenced by Solution Heat Treatment