Is conceptual vagueness an asset? Resilience research from the perspective of philosophy of science

Research output: Working paperWorking papers

Authors

  • Sebastian Strunz
Is conceptual vagueness an asset or a liability? By weighing arguments from philosophy of science and applying them to the concept of resilience, I address this question. I first sketch the wide spectrum of resilience concepts that ranges from concise concepts to the vague perspective of “resilience thinking”. Subsequently, I set out the methodological arguments in favor and against conceptual vagueness. While traditional philosophy of science emphasizes precision and conceptual clarity as precondition for empirical science, alternative views highlight vagueness as fuel for creative and pragmatic problem-solving. Reviewing this discussion, I argue that a trade-off between vagueness and precision exists, which is to be solved differently depending on the research context. In some contexts research benefits from conceptual vagueness while in others it depends on precision. Assessing the specific example of “resilience thinking” in detail, I propose a restructuring of the conceptual framework which explicitly distinguishes descriptive, evaluative and transformative aspects.
Original languageEnglish
Place of PublicationLüneburg
PublisherInstitut für Volkswirtschaftslehre der Universität Lüneburg
Number of pages29
Publication statusPublished - 2011

Documents

Recently viewed

Activities

  1. SEM-A2 – Search Engine Marketing Account Aggregation
  2. Input: Politische Kommunikation in der Transformation?
  3. AMLE, JBR, SJM, SBUR: Meet the Editors
  4. Fish & Chips. Mediengeschichten der Swarm Intelligence zwischen Ozean und Computer
  5. Mitglied des IFIP-Beirats, Sitzung des IFIP-Beirats
  6. Queer_Un_Konferenz "Women Know Your Limits"
  7. Digitalisierung als Herausforderung
  8. Spotlight on professional development for teachers: Which teachers benefit most from a PD workshop?
  9. Graduate School (Organisation)
  10. Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz Universität Hannover (Externe Organisation)
  11. Négritude: Hausenstein and Senghor
  12. Evaluation of a project submitted for financial support to Humbold Foundation. Coordinator in Humbold Foundation: Koegel Annette
  13. Das Ereignis in Einsteins Relativität
  14. Disseminating inquiry-based science education through “Mysteries” in professional development courses mit Anja Lembens
  15. "Play and Community". Enacting a Virtual Stage through Co-Creation
  16. Hautlichkeit. 2014
  17. Journal of Cleaner Production (Zeitschrift)
  18. Ich-Gebrauch in studentischen Texten
  19. Developing Peer Feedback Expertise: Effects of a Face-to-Face Versus Video-Based Feedback Environment
  20. Transcribing nonverbal elements
  21. n-1. Swarming zwischen kollektiver Kollaboration und Computersimulation
  22. Förderung fachbezogener Reflexivität in der Englischlehrer*innenbildung durch Peer Feedback-basierte E-Portfolioaufgaben - Eine explorative Mixed Methods-Studie
  23. International Conference on Public Policy - ICPP 2015
  24. Driving Anger and Driving Anger Expression of Japanese Drivers
  25. Reviewer in recruitment commission for external university
  26. Fakultät Bildung (Organisation)
  27. New York Universität
  28. Valorisation of food waste for lactic acid production
  29. Globalization’s Limits to the Ecological State? The implications of global inter-regional connectedness for the state’s capacity to govern environmental sustainability (with A. Lenschow)
  30. Energy Sources and Environmental Technology Conference 1998
  31. 11. Hamburger Graduiertenforum 2012
  32. Das Flüchtige - Das Erinnern - Das Verschwinden
  33. Rijksuniversiteit Groningen
  34. Workshop: EFL Escape Room planen und beforschen.