Institutional Proxy Representatives of Future Generations: A Comparative Analysis of Types and Design Features

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

Future generations will be strongly affected by political decisions made today (e.g., by the long-term consequences of climate change). According to the democratic all-affected principle, the interests of everyone affected by political decisions should be considered in the political decision-making process. Future generations cannot influence democratic decision-making, since they do not yet exist. Election-based democratic incentive systems are said to make it difficult to consider the needs of future generations today. Surprisingly, however, since the early 1990s, an increasing number of democracies have established what could be called institutional proxy representatives of future generations (proxies), i.e., public bodies with institutionalized access to government and/or parliament that introduce the construed interests of future generations into the political decision-making process. Proxies help to consider future generations’ interests alongside the interests of current constituencies. After concept building, this comparative study searches all liberal democracies and identifies 25 proxies, with heterogeneous institutional designs. By employing membership criteria, three types are distinguished: (a) expertise-driven independent guardians (type I), (b) political or administrative advisory and coordination bodies (type II), and (c) sustainability stakeholder councils or committees (type III). They vary considerably in their formal capacity to influence political decision-making (i.e., on what legal basis they were provided with what instruments to address which phases of the policy process and which branches of government). Overall, they should not be overburdened with expectations. While they are usually equipped with the tools to voice the (construed) interests of future generations, they often lack the capacity to act as watchdogs with teeth when ignored.

Original languageEnglish
Article number7745
JournalPolitics and Governance
Volume12
Pages (from-to)1-21
Number of pages21
ISSN2183-2463
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 08.03.2024

Bibliographical note

Funding Information:
Former versions of this article were presented at the ECPR General Conferences in Innsbruck (2022) and Prague (2023). I thank all panel chairs and participants, as well as the editors of this thematic issue and three anonymous reviewers, for their valuable feedback. I acknowledge support from the German Research Foundation (DFG).

Publisher Copyright:
© 2024 by the author(s), licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY).

    Research areas

  • Politics - democracy, political representation
  • Sustainability Governance - all‐affected principle, future generations, institutions, intergenerational justice, sustainability governance, sustainable development

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Informal and formal lesson planning in school internships
  2. How Political Careers affect Prime-Ministerial Performance
  3. Healthy Eating and Physical Activity in Schools in Europe
  4. Eye-tracking methodology in mathematics education research
  5. Exploring the dark and unexpected sides of digitalization
  6. Developments in Qualitative Mindfulness Practice Research
  7. Das standardessentielle Patent und die FRAND-Lizenz Teil 2
  8. Das standardessentielle Patent und die FRAND-Lizenz Teil 1
  9. BRANGE EFFECTS IN HEDONIC EVALUATION OF OLFACTORY STIMULI
  10. Bat pest control contributes to food security in Thailand
  11. Adapting and evolving-learning place cooperation in change
  12. A review of fire effects across South American ecosystems
  13. The informed society - Final report of SAFECOAST action 2
  14. The future of people and nature in Southern Transylvania
  15. Schreib-Lese-Prozesse, Lehrprozesse und Unterrichtsprozesse
  16. Parsing Causal Models – An Instance Segmentation Approach
  17. Paradoxien des Schreibens in der Bildungssprache Deutsch
  18. Network-based analysis of Lagrangian transport and mixing
  19. Language - Text - Bildung. Essays in Honour of Beate Dreike
  20. Kontrolle durch Transparenz - Transparenz durch Kontrolle
  21. International Sustainability Standards and Certification
  22. How price path characteristics shape investment behavior
  23. Fallarbeit als Angebot – fallbasiertes Lernen als Nutzung
  24. Environmental Regulation and Sustainable Competitiveness
  25. The role of business models for sustainable consumption
  26. Teaching the Teachers about Language Support Strategies
  27. Sustainable Management compensation and ESG performance
  28. Safeguarding Children’s Rights in Residential Child Care
  29. Psychological training for entrepreneurs to take action
  30. Ins Netz und hin zu gesellschaftlich gewünschten Medien
  31. Forschendes Lernen in der angewandten Sozialpsychologie
  32. Examens standardisés et représentations de l’examinateur
  33. Editorial: Die intime Stadt – Kulturen queerer Verbindung
  34. Die USA als Zentrum der internationalen Tabakwirtschaft
  35. Die Entwicklung des europäischen Arbeitsrechts 2011/2012
  36. Das Größenverständnis folgt keiner festen Stufenfolge
  37. Current Research on Entrepreneurship and SME Management
  38. Credit Constraints and the Extensive Margins of Exports
  39. Computergestütztes Repetitorium der Elementarmathematik
  40. Academic discipline and risk perception of technologies
  41. Wer oder was bestimmt "Wirklichkeiten" in Organisationen?
  42. Ver- und Zurück-rückungen in und von "Alice in Wonderland"
  43. Special issue: Frameworks for Sustainability Management
  44. Sharing Economy - Auf dem Weg in eine neue Konsumkultur?
  45. Senkungen als Folge der Rohstoffförderung in Lüneburg