(Dis) integrated valuation: Assessing the information gaps in ecosystem service appraisals for governance support

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • D.N. Barton
  • E. Kelemen
  • J. Dick
  • E. Gómez-Baggethun
  • S. Jacobs
  • C.M.A. Hendriks
  • M. Termansen
  • M. García- Llorente
  • E. Primmer
  • R. Dunford
  • P.A. Harrison
  • F. Turkelboom
  • H. Saarikoski
  • J. van Dijk
  • G.M. Rusch
  • I. Palomo
  • V.J. Yli-Pelkonen
  • L. Carvalho
  • F. Baró
  • J. Langemeyer
  • J. Tjalling van der Wal
  • P. Mederly
  • J.A. Priess
  • S. Luque
  • P. Berry
  • R. Santos
  • D. Odee
  • G. Martines Pastur
  • G. García Blanco
  • S-R. Saarela
  • D. Silaghi
  • G. Pataki
  • F. Masi
  • A. Vădineanu
  • R. Mukhopadhyay
  • D.M. Lapola

The operational challenges of integrated ecosystem service (ES) appraisals are determined by study purpose, system complexity and uncertainty, decision-makers’ requirements for reliability and accuracy of methods, and approaches to stakeholder–science interaction in different decision contexts. To explore these factors we defined an information gap hypothesis, based on a theory of cumulative uncertainty in ES appraisals. When decision context requirements for accuracy and reliability increase, and the expected uncertainty of the ES appraisal methods also increases, the likelihood of methods being used is expected to drop, creating a potential information gap in governance. In order to test this information gap hypothesis, we evaluate 26 case studies and 80 ecosystem services appraisals in a large integrated EU research project. We find some support for a decreasing likelihood of ES appraisal methods coinciding with increasing accuracy and reliability requirements of the decision-support context, and with increasing uncertainty. We do not find that information costs are the explanation for this information gap, but rather that the research project interacted mostly with stakeholders outside the most decision-relevant contexts. The paper discusses how alternative definitions of integrated valuation can lead to different interpretations of decision-support information, and different governance approaches to dealing with uncertainty.

Original languageEnglish
JournalEcosystem Services
Volume29
Issue numberC
Pages (from-to)529-541
Number of pages13
ISSN2212-0416
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.02.2018

    Research areas

  • Integrated valuation, Ecosystem service appraisal, Ecosystem service governance, Information costs, Uncertainty, Valuation, Eccosystem services cascade
  • Sustainability Science

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Functional complementarity and specialisation
  2. Attention and Information Acquisition
  3. The Effects of Social Interaction and Social Norm Compliance in Pay-What-You-Want Situations
  4. Chemotaxonomy of Pochonia and other conidial fungi with Verticillium-like anamorphs
  5. What Triggers Corporate Sustainability
  6. Elevated air carbon dioxide concentrations increase dissolved carbon leaching from a cropland soil
  7. How do conflicts impact change in family businesses?
  8. Measuring Effective Democracy
  9. Fence-sitters no more
  10. Evaluation of Magnesium Die-Casting Alloys for Elevated Temperature Applications
  11. Expected climate change consequences and their role in explaining individual risk judgments.
  12. Habitat management on multiple spatial scales can enhance bee pollination and crop yield in tropical homegardens
  13. Microstructural investigations of MG-AL alloys containing small amount of SiC nucleants
  14. Works Councils in the Production Process
  15. The Rise and Fall of Electricity Distribution Cooperatives in Germany
  16. Characterization and ranking of biodiversity hotspots: centres of species richness and endemism
  17. Temporary exports and characteristics of destination countries
  18. The outcome of coaching and training for self-employment. A statistical evaluation of outside assistance support programs for unemployed business founders in Germany
  19. Was fehlt in der EVS?
  20. Microstructure investigation of Mg-10Gd-1La containing alloy subjected to fatigue deformation
  21. Fahrverhalten in Abhängigkeit diskreter Emotionen unterschiedlicher Valenz
  22. Was bringt diese Aufgabe?
  23. Higher productivity in importing German manufacturing firms
  24. The impact of soft-skills training for entrepreneurs in Jamaica
  25. The influence of motivation, opportunity, ability, and tacitness on repatriate knowledge transfer
  26. The effect of extrusion ratio and material flow on the mechanical properties of aluminum profiles solid state recycled from 6060 aluminum alloy chips
  27. Einkommenssituation Selbständiger in der Europäischen Union
  28. Kompetenzentwicklung im Schuljahr nach PISA 2012
  29. Vergleich von Polaritätsprofilen durch Neuheitsfilter
  30. Sustainable Value Added
  31. Traits of dominant plant species drive normalized difference vegetation index in grasslands globally
  32. Choosing between Internet-based psychodynamic versus cognitive behavioral therapy for depression
  33. Spatial patterns of cultural ecosystem services provision in Southern Patagonia
  34. Conflict strength:
  35. The German Bank Restructuring Act: An Economic Perspective
  36. Does more respect from leaders postpone the desire to retire?
  37. Cool weather tourism under global warming:
  38. Unterricht im Lernbereich Globale Entwicklung
  39. Miscounselling in the German Insurance Market-Utility-Orientated Implications for the Meaning of Miscounselling
  40. On the Thermoregulation in the human microvascular system
  41. Relative inequality and poverty in Germany and the United States using alternative equivalence scales
  42. Crown plasticity and neighborhood interactions of European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) in an old-growth forest
  43. Empirische Arbeit