(Dis) integrated valuation: Assessing the information gaps in ecosystem service appraisals for governance support

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • D.N. Barton
  • E. Kelemen
  • J. Dick
  • E. Gómez-Baggethun
  • S. Jacobs
  • C.M.A. Hendriks
  • M. Termansen
  • M. García- Llorente
  • E. Primmer
  • R. Dunford
  • P.A. Harrison
  • F. Turkelboom
  • H. Saarikoski
  • J. van Dijk
  • G.M. Rusch
  • I. Palomo
  • V.J. Yli-Pelkonen
  • L. Carvalho
  • F. Baró
  • J. Langemeyer
  • J. Tjalling van der Wal
  • P. Mederly
  • J.A. Priess
  • S. Luque
  • P. Berry
  • R. Santos
  • D. Odee
  • G. Martines Pastur
  • G. García Blanco
  • S-R. Saarela
  • D. Silaghi
  • G. Pataki
  • F. Masi
  • A. Vădineanu
  • R. Mukhopadhyay
  • D.M. Lapola

The operational challenges of integrated ecosystem service (ES) appraisals are determined by study purpose, system complexity and uncertainty, decision-makers’ requirements for reliability and accuracy of methods, and approaches to stakeholder–science interaction in different decision contexts. To explore these factors we defined an information gap hypothesis, based on a theory of cumulative uncertainty in ES appraisals. When decision context requirements for accuracy and reliability increase, and the expected uncertainty of the ES appraisal methods also increases, the likelihood of methods being used is expected to drop, creating a potential information gap in governance. In order to test this information gap hypothesis, we evaluate 26 case studies and 80 ecosystem services appraisals in a large integrated EU research project. We find some support for a decreasing likelihood of ES appraisal methods coinciding with increasing accuracy and reliability requirements of the decision-support context, and with increasing uncertainty. We do not find that information costs are the explanation for this information gap, but rather that the research project interacted mostly with stakeholders outside the most decision-relevant contexts. The paper discusses how alternative definitions of integrated valuation can lead to different interpretations of decision-support information, and different governance approaches to dealing with uncertainty.

Original languageEnglish
JournalEcosystem Services
Volume29
Issue numberC
Pages (from-to)529-541
Number of pages13
ISSN2212-0416
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.02.2018

    Research areas

  • Integrated valuation, Ecosystem service appraisal, Ecosystem service governance, Information costs, Uncertainty, Valuation, Eccosystem services cascade
  • Sustainability Science

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. A fragile kaleidoskop: institutions, methodologies and outlooks on German popular music (studies)
  2. Mitteilung zur Kopula von Aeshna viridis
  3. Split-Screen-Gesichter
  4. The Importance of School Leaders’ Attitudes and Health Literacy to the Implementation of a Health-Promoting Schools Approach
  5. Traumjob Sportlehrer/in?
  6. Occurrence and fate of the antidiabetic drug metformin and its metabolite guanylurea in the environment and during drinking water treatment
  7. A novel telecoupling framework to assess social relations across spatial scales for ecosystem services research
  8. Biodiversity–stability relationships strengthen over time in a long-term grassland experiment
  9. Identification of phototransformation products of the antiepileptic drug gabapentin
  10. Participation in River Basin Planning Under the Water Framework Directive – Has it Benefitted Good Water Status?
  11. Community Energy in Germany
  12. CO2-Steuer oder Ausweitung des Emissionshandels
  13. Das Bild in der Schrift
  14. Strengthening and ductilizing of magnesium alloying with heavy rare earth elements
  15. Thinking the Problematic
  16. Editorial
  17. Measuring social norms in economics
  18. Hic sunt leones
  19. Market for Corporate Control and CSR
  20. N:P Ratio and the Nature of Nutrient Limitation in Calluna-Dominated Heathlands
  21. Aprendiendo con todos los sentidos en la clase EFE
  22. Persistent career indecision over time: Links with personality, barriers, self-efficacy, and life satisfaction
  23. This was Tomorrow. Die koloniale Moderne und ihre blinden Flecken“
  24. Purpurne Zeichen
  25. §60 Nutzung von Seewasserstraßen
  26. Cybervictimization, self-esteem, and social relationships among German secondary school students
  27. Die Aufgabe der Fünfziger
  28. The Right to Consular Assistance Under International Law
  29. Status of the development of creep resistant magnesium materials for automotive applications
  30. Sobre la transferencia
  31. Sustainable Management compensation and ESG performance
  32. Entwicklung von Instrumenten zur Vermeidung von Lebensmittelabfällen
  33. Notting Hill Gate 3
  34. Correction to