Critical assessment of models for transport of engineered nanoparticles in saturated porous media

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

To reliably assess the fate of engineered nanoparticles (ENP) in soil, it is important to understand the performance of models employed to predict vertical ENP transport. We assess the ability of seven routinely employed particle transport models (PTMs) to simulate hyperexponential (HE), nonmonotonic (NM), linearly decreasing (LD), and monotonically increasing (MI) retention profiles (RPs) and the corresponding breakthrough curves (BTCs) from soil column experiments with ENPs. Several important observations are noted. First, more complex PTMs do not necessarily perform better than simpler PTMs. To avoid applying overparameterized PTMs, multiple PTMs should be applied and the best model selected. Second, application of the selected models to simulate NM and MI profiles results in poor model performance. Third, the selected models can well-approximate LD profiles. However, because the models cannot explicitly generate LD retention, these models have low predictive power to simulate the behavior of ENPs that present LD profiles. Fourth, a term for blocking can often be accounted for by parameter variation in models that do not explicitly include a term for blocking. We recommend that model performance be analyzed for RPs and BTCs separately; simultaneous fitting to the RP and BTC should be performed only under conditions where sufficient parameter validation is possible to justify the selection of a particular model.

Original languageEnglish
JournalEnvironmental Science & Technology
Volume48
Issue number21
Pages (from-to)12732-12741
Number of pages10
ISSN0013-936X
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 04.11.2014
Externally publishedYes

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Autotrophic and heterotrophic microalgae and cyanobacteria cultivation for food and feed
  2. CO2-Steuer oder Ausweitung des Emissionshandels
  3. Deep decarbonization in Germany: A macro-analysis of economic and political challenges of the 'Energiewende' (energy transition)
  4. Forecasting European interest rates in times of financial crisis – What insights do we get from international survey forecasts?
  5. Erdkabel
  6. The Implementation of the National Park Idea in Society
  7. Diversität und Heterogenität
  8. Microstructures, Corrosion and Mechanical Properties of Mg–Si Alloys as Biodegradable Implant Materials
  9. John Rawls
  10. Garzweiler II
  11. Pre-service teachers’ perceptions of school development
  12. Bionik
  13. Christian Boltanski's Failed Meta-Archive
  14. EU Asylum Policies
  15. "Forschendes Lernen in der Schule"
  16. Gene flow across large distances in the cavity-nesting wasp Deuteragenia subintermedia in a central European forest
  17. Robbins, Lionel Charles
  18. Germany must invest more in its future
  19. IPR für eine bessere Welt
  20. Competence Assessment in Education
  21. Effect of biaxial compressive stress state on the microstructure evolution and deformation compatibility of rolled sheet Mg alloy AZ31 at room temperature
  22. Paradoxe Korruption
  23. Engel der Effizienz
  24. The role of media for consumers' inflation expectation formation
  25. In situ compressive investigations on the effects of solid solution Gd on the texture and lattice strain evolution of Mg
  26. Die Schreibwerkstatt Mehrsprachigkeit an der Universität Hamburg
  27. How do international sanctions end?
  28. The legal dimensions of rule of law promotion in EU foreign policy
  29. Inventionen 1