Contextualizing certification and auditing: Soy certification and access of local communities to land and water in Brazil

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

The massive expansion of soy production in Brazil has contributed to a loss of access for local communities to land and water, particularly in highly dynamic frontier regions in the Cerrado. Soy certification standards like the Roundtable on Responsible Soy (RTRS) contain principles that are supposed to prevent such problems. In this paper, we examine the extent to which certification and auditing have served to protect local communities’ access to land and water in western Bahía state in the Cerrado’s Matopiba region. We draw on findings from field research in Brazil and western Bahía, 72 semi-structured interviews with corporate, state and civil society actors, and a systematic analysis of audit reports from RTRS-certified farms in Bahía.

We find that auditing practices are not effective in protecting the rights and access of local communities to land and water due to three inter-related sets of factors: 1) the business-dominated nature of the drafting and content of the RTRS standard, 2) the structural limitations and everyday practices of auditing, and 3) domestic and local contextual factors in Brazil and western Bahía.

This study aims to contribute to a re-thinking and re-assessment of certification and auditing practices and suggests that new approaches are required to govern global commodity chains in a more environmentally just way. We advocate for a locally embedded and community-sensitive perspective in research on certification and auditing, to complement previous research in the fields of critical political economy and sustainability governance.
Original languageEnglish
Article number105281
JournalWorld Development
Volume140
Number of pages12
ISSN0305-750X
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.04.2021

Bibliographical note

This work was supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) under grant no. LE 2396/4-1 through the project “GOVERNECT - Governance of Environmental Sustainability in Telecoupled Systems of Global Inter-Regional Connectedness” (see https://sustainability-governance.net/governect ).

    Research areas

  • Sustainability Governance - environmental governance, RTRS, Commodity chain, Access rights, Latin America, Brazil

Recently viewed

Activities

  1. Workshop ‚Independent Local Lists – A comparative perspective’ - 2007
  2. Are cities mediators of uncertainty in the field of deportation?
  3. Strategies for the Control of Water Treatment by Stripping and Injection of CO2
  4. Symposium "Art and its Frames - Continuity and Change" 2014
  5. Workshop "Biodiversity and pollination services – from basic and applied science to stakeholders and policy" 2012
  6. Process Tracing Methodology - 2011
  7. The impact of information on diabetes patients' acceptance of internet-based depression interventions: a randomized controlled trial.
  8. Explaining the performance of participatory and collaborative governance in addressing long-term environmental policy issues
  9. Purposeful Work Symposium (PWS)
  10. Reactivity on a student-centered recording system – a video-based longitudinal study in primary education
  11. HyperKult XI - Computer als Medium: Das Unsichtbare - 2002
  12. Invited talk at the Lodz University of Technology
  13. IDG Summit 2023
  14. Preliminary results of the state of the art study on scaling and corrosion.
  15. Quantity, Quality, Trust: Dilemmas and Strategies of Museum Documentation in the Age of AI
  16. Playing guitar while playing video games: An experiment with students learning to play the guitar by playing Rocksmith
  17. meson press (Verlag)
  18. 'Can you play a new CD,please?' Speech act representation in EFL textbooks: An interlanguage pragmatic appraisal (Universität Gießen, invited talk)
  19. ‘Towards relational practices of world-making: entrepreneurship from a more-than-human perspective’.
  20. Rationality and affect – instructions as a form of care in Russian protest online networks

Publications

  1. Topic selection and development in learner-native speaker voice-based telecollaborative discourse
  2. Effects of an expressive writing intervention (EWI) with women treated for breast cancer explored with recurrence quantification analysis (RQA) of changes in text structure - a proof-of-concept study
  3. Conceptualizing protected area research in a transdisciplinary
  4. Multiobjective optimal control of fluid mixing
  5. Logistic Operating Curves in Theory and Practice
  6. Robust approximate fixed-time tracking control for uncertain robot manipulators
  7. Hydrograph analysis and basef low separation
  8. Deconstructing the Theoretical Language of Process Research
  9. An introductional lecture on chaotic systems through Lorenz attractor and forced Lotka Volterra equation for interdisciplinary education
  10. Introduction to the challenges and chances regarding the utilization of nitrogen-rich by-products and waste streams
  11. Reliability and Validity of Assessing User Satisfaction With Web-Based Health Interventions
  12. Knowledge integration
  13. A comparison between private and public access rules to bottlenecks - experiences and expectations from telecommunication and energy
  14. Migration-Based Multilingualism in the English as a Foreign Language Classroom
  15. Using frequency tagging to investigate social processing in autism
  16. ℓp-norm multiple kernel learning
  17. Editorial introduction to the special issue on crises at work
  18. Comparison of an Electrochemical and Luminescence-Based Oxygen Measuring System for Use in the Biodegradability Testing According to Closed Bottle Test (OECD 301D)
  19. Creative Network Communities in the Translocal Space of Digital Networks
  20. The Role of Formalisation, Participation and Context in the Success of Public Involvement Mechanisms in Resource Management
  21. »CO2 causes a hole in the atmosphere« Using laypeople’s conceptions as a starting point to communicate climate change
  22. Influence of Dy in solid solution on the degradation behavior of binary Mg-Dy alloys in cell culture medium
  23. Socio-technical instruments in the field of Integrated Water Resources Management
  24. An Adaptive Resonance Regulator Design for Motion Control of Intake Valves in Camless Engine Systems
  25. De-Anonymizing Anonymous
  26. A Hybrid Hydraulic Piezo Actuator for Camless Internal Combustion Engines Controlled with an MPC and an Affine Feedforward Structure
  27. Non-acceptances in context
  28. Thanking and responding to thanks in American English: Language patterning and contextual appropriateness