Choosing between Internet-based psychodynamic versus cognitive behavioral therapy for depression: a pilot preference study

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Robert Johansson
  • Anna Nyblom
  • Per Carlbring
  • Pim Cuijpers
  • Gerhard Andersson

Background: Major depression is a world-wide problem that can be treated with various forms of psychotherapy. There is strong research support for treating major depression using cognitive behavior therapy delivered in the format of guided self-help via the Internet (ICBT). Recent research also suggests that psychodynamic psychotherapy can be delivered as guided self-help via the Internet (IPDT) and that it seem to be as effective as ICBT for mild to moderate depression. However, no head-to-head comparison between the two treatments exists. In the field of Internet interventions it is largely unexplored if treatment preference affects outcome and adherence. Methods: Participants were allocated to IPDT or ICBT based on their stated preference. More than half of the participants preferred ICBT (N = 30) over IPDT (N = 14). Differences in efficacy between treatments were explored. Correlations between strength of preference and treatment outcome, adherence to treatment and completion of the whole treatment program were explored. Data were collected before and after treatment, as well as in a 7-month follow-up. Results: During the treatment period, both programs performed equally well in reducing symptoms. More participants who received IPDT completed the entire program. At follow-up, mixed-effects models showed that participants who chose ICBT improved more in terms of quality of life. The ICBT group also had a significant increase in participants who recovered from their depression from post-treatment to follow-up. Exploratory analyses indicated that strength of preference was correlated with adherence to treatment and completion of the whole program, and long-term outcome for the ICBT group. Conclusions: Few differences were found during the acute treatment phase, but the long-term effects are in favor of ICBT. Strength of preference for treatment seems to have a predictive value. Further research comparing the efficacy of ICBT and IPDT, and the effects of preference matching and strength of preference, is warranted.Trial registration: This trial is a continuation of the study registered as NCT01324050 at Clinicaltrials.gov.

Original languageEnglish
Article number268
JournalBMC Psychiatry
Volume13
Number of pages9
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 18.10.2013

Bibliographical note

Funding Information:
The study was sponsored in part by the Swedish council for working and life research, the Swedish research council, and Linköping University (Professor contract). The authors report no financial relationships with commercial interests. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. We would like to thank Sigrid Ekbladh, Amanda Hebert, Sara Möller, Stephanie Poysti and Sarah Vigerland for acting as therapists in the study.

    Research areas

  • Health sciences
  • Cognitive behavioral therapy, Depression, Internet-based psychotherapy, Psychodynamic therapy, Treatment preferences

Documents

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. Apologies and Corpus Pragmatics
  2. PSK-Kinder
  3. Effects of free-air CO 2 enrichment and nitrogen supply on grain quality parameters and elemental composition of wheat and barley grown in a crop rotation
  4. In-Beziehung-Setzen
  5. Foreign and Domestic Takeovers in Germany: Cherry-picking and Lemon-grabbing
  6. Mathematics teachers’ domain-specific professional knowledge: conceptualization and test construction in COACTIV
  7. Nitrogen losses from fertilizers applied to maize, wheat and rice in the North China Plain
  8. Patterns and hotspots of carabid beetle diversity in the Palaearctic – insights from a hyperdiverse invertebrate taxon
  9. A sticky affair
  10. Friction analyses in twisted and helical profile extrusion of aluminum alloys
  11. Die Rentenreform in der Diskussion
  12. A Lyapunov-based Adaptive Control Law for an Electromagnetic Actuator
  13. The Challenge of Long-Term Climate Change
  14. Course Evaluations
  15. Do red herrings swim in circles?
  16. In situ studies of light metals with synchrotron radiation and neutrons
  17. Multiple import sourcing
  18. Exports and Firm Characteristics in Germany: A Survey of Empirical Studies (1991 to 2011)
  19. The reputation costs of executive misconduct accusations
  20. Relative inequality and poverty in Germany and the United States using alternative equivalence scales
  21. Export entry, export exit and productivity in German manufacturing industries
  22. Fourier methods for quasi-periodic oscillations
  23. Dating the Neanderthal environment
  24. Gewalt
  25. Ecophysiological isotope tools for characterising the drought sensitivity of Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii Mirb. Franco)
  26. Simulationsbasierte Optimierung der Reihenfolgeplanung am Beispiel eines Liniensorters in der Automobilindustrie
  27. Species diversity of forest floor biota in non-native Douglas-fir stands is similar to that of native stands
  28. Öffentlichkeiten
  29. Gaseous nitrogen losses from urea applied to maize on a calcareous fluvo-aquic soil in the North China Plain
  30. Effect of heat treatment on the microstructure and creep behavior of Mg-Sn-Ca alloys
  31. Palaeodose underestimation of heated quartz in red-TL dating of volcanic contexts
  32. What is green worth to you? Activating environmental values lowers price sensitivity towards electric vehicles
  33. Parketto
  34. Der Kompass "Nachhaltiger Konsum"
  35. In situ tensile texture analysis of a new Mg-RE alloy
  36. Verteilungseffekte von Kapazitätsmechanismen
  37. Optimal maintenance in the supply chain
  38. BRANGE EFFECTS IN HEDONIC EVALUATION OF OLFACTORY STIMULI
  39. Coherence in mathematics teacher education
  40. Case Study