Anti-EU and anti-LGBT attitudes in Poland: Considering quantitative and qualitative evidence

Research output: Journal contributionsJournal articlesResearchpeer-review

Authors

  • Joanna Chojnicka

The purpose of this study is to investigate anti-EU and anti-LGBT attitudes in Poland on the basis of quantitative evidence (statistical data) and qualitative evidence (discourse analysis of statements expressed on the Internet). As Euroscepticism seems to frequently appear in conjunction with prejudice against LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual and transsexual or transgender) persons, the task of this article is to find out whether they may have a common foundation and what it may be. A possible answer, as the article argues, is that both attitudes could be considered symptoms of a deeper, more wide-ranging and fundamental problem - A fear, tension, or anxiety caused by social change, especially the fragmentation of dominant collective (national) identity. The case for such an interpretation of the situation is first made on the basis of existing academic literature and statistical data provided by Eurobarometer and the Polish Public Opinion Research Centre (Centrum Badania Opinii Spolecznej, CBOS). However, as the text further argues, such quantitative methods have their limitations and should be supported and illustrated with qualitative studies. The article thus proposes an alternative discourse-oriented approach, namely critical discourse analysis (CDA). This approach is used to conduct an introductory, presentational analysis of some examples of anti-EU and anti-LGBT discourse found on the Internet. This analysis shows that sexual minorities represent values so strange and foreign to Polish conservatives that they can only be conceptualized as something imposed by the power which is both new and distant-by Brussels. And the other way round, the European Union's liberalism and espousal of human rights, including women's and LGBT rights, makes it impossible for the conservative parts of the Polish society to accept a "European identity". This means that Euroscepticism and LGBT prejudice are not just occasionally, coincidentally connected expressions of an underlying resistance to change, but that a closer relationship exists between them. Namely, the conservative reluctance or hostility towards both the EU and LGBT is caused by their incompatibility with the patriotic and religious national identity construction.

Original languageEnglish
JournalBaltic Journal of European Studies
Volume5
Issue number2
Pages (from-to)30-55
Number of pages26
ISSN2228-0588
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01.10.2015

Documents

DOI

Recently viewed

Publications

  1. "Silver Workers" - Arbeiten im (Un-)Ruhestand
  2. "Ah no honestly we’re okay"
  3. Signs, traces and integration of the sustainability concept in higher agricultural education in Germany
  4. Who Cares? Arbeitsteilung in Familien als letzte Hürde auf dem Weg zur Gleichberechtigung
  5. The contribution of canopy species to overall ant diversity (Hymenoptera: Formicidae) in temperate and tropical ecosystems
  6. Experiencing the global dimension of sustainability
  7. Vertrauen
  8. Wege zum freien Sprechdenken
  9. A trilogy of inequalities: Land ownership, forest cover and ecosystem services distribution
  10. Ins Bild kommen
  11. Theorie und Praxis kooperativer Rhetorik
  12. Political Science and the Emergence of Democracy in Central and Eastern Europe
  13. Organisation elektronischer Beschaffung
  14. Salafisten in Afrika: nicht zwingend Wegbereiter des Terrorismus
  15. "Something is not quite right" - Two cinematic narratives about decision-making after prenatal diagnosis
  16. Energiegenossenschaften -das Erfolgsmodell braucht neue Dynamik
  17. Nach Bourdieu
  18. Leistungsänderung und ihre Auswirkung auf die Vergütung des Auftragnehmers
  19. Zur Gerechtigkeitsfrage in sozialen (Frauen-)Berufen
  20. Theoretische Rahmungen von (Gewalt-) Situationen
  21. Novel Thought
  22. Lagrangian Coherent Sets as transport barriers in convection
  23. Innovative Unternehmensgründung
  24. Weltweite Energiewende dank Solarenergie
  25. Crisis - Unrest - Commons Sense
  26. Genetic Factors, Cultural Predispositions, Happiness and Gender Equality
  27. Zwischen Animismus und Animation – Krieg und (Virtual) Reality bei Harun Farocki
  28. Deutsche Biotechnologie-KMU: Wettbewerbsvorteile durch Virtuelle Unternehmen?
  29. Oft rüsten hilft viel
  30. Fälligkeit der Forderung aus einer zur Abwendung der Sicherungsvollstreckung geleisteten Prozessbürgschaft - Anmerkung zu BGH, Urt. v. 11. November 2014 (XI ZR 265/13)
  31. Niklas Luhmann am OVG Lüneburg
  32. Wertetransmission und Wertewandel
  33. Das Kunstfeld
  34. Health and Language Integrated Gaming Online (HeaLinGo) as an innovative approach in School Health Promotion
  35. Multikonferenz Wirtschaftsinformatik 2018
  36. Das Leitbild der Mischung im Vergleich
  37. Drei Gesetze - ein Anspruch
  38. Landnahmen, Menschennahmen
  39. §32 Solare Strahlungsenergie
  40. Environmental occurrence and hazard of organic UV stabilizers and UV filters in the sediment of European North and Baltic Seas
  41. Aenictus hoelldobleri sp. n., a new species of the Aenictus ceylonicus group (Hymenoptera, Formicidae) from China, with a key to the Chinese members of the group
  42. Zeugenschaft als philosophisches Problem - Zur Einleitung in diesen Band
  43. Interculturality as background for sustainability
  44. § 260 HGB: Vorlegung bei Auseinandersetzungen
  45. Notting Hill Gate 4