Assessing knowledge cumulation in earth system governance research: An analysis of 100 published ESG papers

Activity: Talk or presentationConference PresentationsResearch

Michael Rose - Speaker

Jens Newig - Speaker

Research in earth system governance (ESG) aspires to be both academically sound and policy-relevant (Biermann et al. 2007, 2012; Burch et al. 2018). Arguably, both objectives require the production of reliable evidence by cumulating – refining, challenging, complementing and synthesizing – existing research (Nutley et al. 2019). In line with a growing focus on evidence cumulation in sustainabiltiy science (Pauliuk 2019), we ask how and to what extent ESG research contributes to evidence production and cumulation.
To this end, we first define what constitutes ESG research as all publications that emerged from the first seven ESG conferences (from Amsterdam 2007 up to Norwich 2014). To be precise, we define the body of ESG research as all journal articles published in or before 2021 which can be attributed unequivocally to an abstract accepted for an ESG conference. We identified 362 publications that match these criteria, of which we further analyse a random set of 100 publications. We show descriptive statistics and network graphs to characterise this body of research.
The resulting set of 100 journal papers were coded for their theoretical, conceptual, normative-prescriptive or empirical orientation. Empirical papers are coded for a qualitative, quantitative, interpretive or meta-analytical research approach, and whether they can generally be regarded as positivist or constructivist (Burch et al. 2018). We coded in what way papers add to, refine, challenge or synthesise existing research, and in what way they contribute to developing shared frameworks, definitions or datasets.
Overall we find that evidence cumulation is still poorly developed within the ESG community. Like the field of environmental policy and governance more generally, ESG research may be characterised as a “fragmented adhocracy” (Whitley 2006), explaining the widespread failure to produce robust and cumulative knowledge .
We close by suggesting a number of avenues for stronger production and cumulation of evidence in the ESG community. These include the development and use of more widely shared core terminology, e.g. through broadly accepted dictionaries and common research protocols, allowing to produce shared and compatible datasets, and meta studies that synthesise existing (case-based) research following shared frameworks. Hence contributing to a growing body of – cumulating – evidence on what “works” in ESG will, so we hope, more likely and more lastingly inform policy and governance.
21.10.2022

Event

2022 Toronto Conference on Earth System Governance

20.10.2224.10.22

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Event: Conference

Recently viewed

Researchers

  1. Claudia Erk

Publications

  1. Remotely sensed effectiveness assessments of protected areas lack a common framework
  2. Teaching the Teachers about Language Support Strategies
  3. Multinomial choice models based on Archimedean copulas
  4. Support from the Internet for Individuals with Mental Disorders
  5. Lung fibroblasts from patients with emphysema show markers of senescence in vitro
  6. A Sampling Framework for Uncertainty in Individual Environmental Decisions
  7. A Fictional Risk Narrative and Its Potential for Social Resonance: Reception of Barbara Kingsolver’s Flight Behavior in Reviews and Reading Groups
  8. Gemachter oder gelebter Tourismus?
  9. Determinants and Consequences of Executive Compensation-Related Shareholder Activism and Say-on-Pay Votes
  10. EEZ-adjacent distant-water fishing as a global security challenge
  11. An Adaptive Two-Stage Observer in the Control of a New Electromagnetic Valve Actuator for Camless Internal Combustion Engines
  12. Investigation of new tool design for incremental profile forming
  13. Does Carbon Disclosure Drive Carbon Performance
  14. Automation in Clinical Laboratories
  15. Increasing personal initiative in small business managers or owners leads to entrepreneurial success: A theory-based controlled randomized field intervention for evidence-based management
  16. The research potential of new types of enterprise data based on surveys from official statistics in Germany
  17. Not Only a Workplace
  18. Who is a Migrant? Abandoning the Nation-State Point of View in the Study of Migration
  19. Wirtschaften in Netzen
  20. Frames of systems change in sustainability transformations: Lessons from sociotechnical systems and circular economy case studies
  21. Der Mensch in Zahlen
  22. The lens of polycentricity
  23. Bimodal Enterprise Architecture Management
  24. Collaborative decision making in sustainable flood risk management
  25. Themes in the development of emotion regulation in childhood and adolescence and a transactional model
  26. Non-local modeling of size effects in amorphous metals
  27. The Impact of TV Ads on the Individual User's Purchasing Behavior
  28. Effect of Temperature and Strain Rate on Formability of Titanium Alloy KS1.2ASN
  29. Lengthscale-dependent modelling of ductile failure in metallic microstructures
  30. Effectiveness of a Web-Based Intervention in Reducing Depression and Sickness Absence
  31. Two types of ‘enough’
  32. Guest Editors of Special Issue: