Performance measurement systems: Beyond generic actions

Publikation: Beiträge in SammelwerkenAufsätze in SammelwerkenForschungbegutachtet

Authors

Over recent decades, academics and practitioners have discussed the weaknesses of traditional and advanced fi nancial performance measures which incorporate cost considerations. In particular, return on investment (ROI) – as a ratio based on historical accounting information – has major shortcomings in measuring the fi nancial results of organizational units and in motivating management. First, it ignores the fi nancial value of intangible assets such as research in progress, human resources and the competitive position. Due to asset valuation, depreciation policy and lack of instruction about the cost of capital, ROI furthermore has serious dysfunctional implications for investment decisions (Copeland, Koller, and Murrin, 2000; Dearden, 1969: 292; Nobel, 1990). To address some of the weaknesses of ROI, EVA has been advocated as an advanced alternative (Stewart, 1991). One of the strengths of EVA is the inclusion of opportunity costs in the performance assessment and hence in managerial decision-making. Additionally, EVA requires detailed adjustments of earnings and invested capital to move away from historical accounting principles towards more economic-based principles. Yet, empirical evidence shows that EVA has only marginally higher explanatory power in explaining stock returns than unaltered accounting fi gures (Biddle, Bowen, and Wallace, 1997). However, since the fi gure relies on past accounting information and disregards many other expectations of market participants, we suggest that the singular focus on such a narrow defi nition of shareholder value could distort fi nancial performance measurement, and motivate management to undertake dysfunctional, short-term actions or gaming at the expense of long-term profi tability. Finally, it should be noted that the conventional wisdom of accounting advocates NPV to be used for managerial decision-making. However, the success of the NPV technique depends on the ability to estimate cash fl ows and the project-specifi c weighted average cost of capital. When evaluating possible investments, many companies tend to focus on cost savings only and hence neglect the measurement of (in-)tangible benefi ts, the opportunity costs of the decision and the project-specifi c risk (Kaplan and Atkinson, 1989; Nobel, 1990).
OriginalspracheEnglisch
TitelThe Routledge Companion to Cost Management
HerausgeberFalconer Mitchell, Hanne Nørreklit, Morten Jakobsen
Anzahl der Seiten18
ErscheinungsortLondon
VerlagRoutledge Taylor & Francis Group
Erscheinungsdatum22.08.2013
Seiten342-359
Aufsatznummer20
ISBN (Print)978-0-415-59247-5
ISBN (elektronisch)978-1-136-23428-6
DOIs
PublikationsstatusErschienen - 22.08.2013
Extern publiziertJa

DOI

Zuletzt angesehen

Publikationen

  1. Mechanisms of dialectical change
  2. States of Comparability
  3. Between world models and model worlds
  4. Conservatives are less accurate than liberals at recognizing false climate statements, and disinformation makes conservatives less discerning
  5. Evidence-Based Management
  6. Effects of facebook activities on the performance of start-ups
  7. Corporate hedging for different production cycles with the wavelet-approach
  8. A call for statistical editors in ecology
  9. Resource-Based View und Personalpolitik
  10. The Influence of Maximum Strength Performance in Seated Calf Raises on Counter Movement Jump and Squat Jump in Elite Junior Basketball Players
  11. Teaching entrepreneurship as lived experience through ‘wonderment exercises’
  12. Housing, financialization, and migration in the current global crisis
  13. ORCHIDEE-SOM
  14. From Making to Displaying: The Role of Organizational Space in Showing Creative Coolness at the Volkshotel
  15. What workers want: job satisfaction in the U.S.
  16. Introduction
  17. Lagrangian perspectives on turbulent superstructures in Rayleigh-Bénard convection
  18. Ecosystem services as a boundary object for sustainability
  19. The predictive chameleon
  20. Determinants in Pay-What-You-Want Pricing Decisions—A Cross-Country Study
  21. The politics of expertise and ignorance in the field of migration management
  22. Pesticide peak concentration reduction in a small vegetated treatment system controlled by chemograph shape
  23. Does outcome expectancy predict outcomes in online depression prevention? Secondary analysis of randomised-controlled trials
  24. Klassensprachen - Some Preliminary Theses