Implementing the No Harm Principle in International Economic Law: A Comparison between Measure-Based Rules and Effect-Based Rules

Publikation: Beiträge in ZeitschriftenZeitschriftenaufsätzeForschungbegutachtet

Authors

The regulatory nature of measure-based rules is distinctively different from that of effect-based rules. While a breach of a measure-based rule is determined by the actual measure, in effect-based rules a breach is to be determined against the actual effects of the measure. Effect-based rules can be regarded as implementing the no harm principle that proscribes measures to cause adverse effects to other states, while seeking to reconcile colliding interests on a practical level and taking into account the detrimental effects created for others. Measure-based rules, being the norm in the jurisprudence of the World Trade Organisation (WTO) are to be examined by panels and the Appellate Body in light of the architecture, structure and design' of a measure: It is not necessary to demonstrate the occurrence of adverse effects. In contrast, the regulatory framework dealing with the harmful effect of measures is located, especially, in the rules governing non-violation complaints and within the rules on actionable subsidies. While most WTO obligations may clearly be categorized as either measure-or effect-based rules, certain rules or at least their interpretation seem to blur the line between these two categories. This article examines and discusses both regulatory types and ultimately argues that, while measure-based rules provide for more regulatory stringency, effect-based rules leave greater policy-space and can succeed in breaking deadlocks in negotiations under certain circumstances. In such circumstances, they may therefore support the further development of certain yet under-regulated areas of international economic law.

OriginalspracheEnglisch
ZeitschriftJournal of International Economic Law
Jahrgang20
Ausgabenummer4
Seiten (von - bis)807-828
Anzahl der Seiten22
ISSN1369-3034
DOIs
PublikationsstatusErschienen - 01.12.2017
Extern publiziertJa

DOI

Zuletzt angesehen

Publikationen

  1. Teaching pragmatic competence with corpora: Intensification in expressions of gratitude across varieties
  2. Definitions and Measures of Party Institutionalization in New Personal Politics
  3. Behavior of microstructure and mechanical properties in the stir zone of friction stir welded ME21 magnesium alloy
  4. A robust cascade sliding mode control for a hybrid piezo-hydraulic actuator in camless internal combustion engines
  5. Comparison through conversation
  6. Mechanical properties and corrosion behavior of Mg-Gd-Ca-Zr alloys for medical applications
  7. Übungsprogramm im Sattel
  8. Approaching the Cognitive and Social Functions of World of Warcraft Fan-Comics
  9. Incentives Matter, But What Do They Mean? Understanding the Meaning of Market Coordination
  10. „Das weiß aber oben quasi keiner“.
  11. Financing Consumer (Co-)Ownership of Renewable Energy Sources
  12. Assumptions in ecosystem service assessments
  13. Systematic study of the effect of non-uniform seal stiffness on the contact stress in flat-faced soft-seated spring operated pressure relief valves
  14. Export intensity and plant characteristics
  15. Exporttätigkeit und Firmengröße
  16. Inside the Jazzomat
  17. Predicting Therapy Success and Costs for Personalized Treatment Recommendations Using Baseline Characteristics
  18. Playing by Their Rules
  19. Cognition in High-Frequency Trading
  20. Finding the Balance
  21. Solution heat treatment on mechanical properties and corrosion of extruded Mg5Gd compared to pure Mg
  22. Medien, Universitäten, Lügen
  23. The spillover effect of mimicry: Being mimicked by one person increases prosocial behavior toward another person
  24. Umweltökonomie
  25. Basel II Rahmenwerk
  26. Transdisciplinary learning to foster sustainable development
  27. Computer Vision for Analyzing Children’s Lived Experiences
  28. The relationship between intragenerational and intergenerational ecological justice
  29. Atomrecht im Wandel
  30. Generalist social bees maximize diversity intake in plant species-rich and resource-abundant environments
  31. Othering and Same-ing for the Young. Expanding the Theoretical and Material Horizons of Imagology with Children's Literature
  32. Monitoring European wildcat Felis silvestris populations using scat surveys in central Spain
  33. Do Populists Govern Differently? The Management of the Italian M5S-League Coalition in Comparative Perspective
  34. Ordo-Responsibility
  35. Understanding Sustainability Performance in Business Organizations
  36. Integrating rural development and biodiversity conservation in Central Romania
  37. Dynamic capabilities and sustainable supply chain management
  38. Gender and (Un)Sustainability—Can Communication Solve a Conflict of Norms?
  39. Beyond Biodiversity Conservation